212 ON THE TPJNITY. [bOOK VIII.
body is moved, there is no way opened to our eyes to see the
mind, a thing which cannot be seen by the eyes ; but we
]oerceive something to be contained in that bulk, such as is
contained in ourselves, so as to move in like manner our own
bulk, which is the life and the soul. Neither is this, as it
were, the property of human foresight and reason, since brute
animals also perceive that not only they themselves live, but
also other brute animals interchangeably, and the one the
other, and that we ourselves do so. Neither do they see our
souls, save from the movements, of the body, and that imme-
diately and most easily by some natural agreement. There-
fore we both know the mind of any one from our own, and
believe also from our own of him whom we do not know.
Por not only do we perceive that there is a mind, but we
can also know what a mind is, by reflecting upon our own
:
for we have a mind. But whence do we know what a right-
eous man is ? For we said above that we love the apostle
for no other reason except that he is a righteous mind. We
know, then, what a righteous man also is, just as we know
what a mind is. But what a mind is, as has been said, we
know from ourselves, for there is a mind in us. But whence
do we know what a righteous man is, ifwe are not righteous ?
But if no one but he who is righteous knows what is a right-
eous man, no one but a righteous man loves a righteous man
;
for one cannot love him whom one believes to be righteous,
for this very reason that one does believe him to be righteous,
if one does not know what it is to be righteous ; according to
that which we have shown above, that no one loves what he
believes and does not see, except by some rule of a general
or special notion. And if for this reason no one but a right-
eous man loves a righteous man, how will any one wish to be
a righteous manwho is not yet so ? For no one wishes to be
that which he does not love. But he certainly must wish to
be righteous, who, not yet being righteous, means to be so;
and in order that he may wish to be so, he loves the righteous
man. Therefore, even he who is not yet righteous loves the
righteous man. But he cannot love the righteous man, who is
ignorant what a righteous man is. Accordingly, even he who
is not yet righteous, knows what a righteous man is. Whence