This Apology was brought to
Rufinus at Aquileia by a merchant who was leaving again in two days
(522). Chromatius no doubt urged him, as he urged Jerome (520) not to
continue the controversy and he yielded. He wrote, however, a private
letter to Jerome, which has been lost, sending him an accurate copy of
his Apology, and while declining public controversy, yet declaring that
he could have said even more than before, and divulged things which
would have been worse to Jerome than death. Jerome in his answer
written a.d. 403, which forms B. iii of his
Apology, declares that the controversy is Rufinus’ fault, and
defends his friends for their conduct towards him, even in holding back
the conciliatory letter written in 399; but shows how a way might still
be open for friendship. He touches again upon most of the points dwelt
on in the previous books, defending himself and accusing Rufinus, and
ends by declaring that his bitter reply was necessitated first by
Rufinus’ threats, and secondly by his abhorrence of heresy, from
all complicity with which he must at any price clear
himself.