465
Book III.
Chapter I.
In the first book of our answer to the work of Celsus, who had boastfully entitled the
treatise which he had composed against us A True Discourse, we have gone through, as you
enjoined, my faithful Ambrosius, to the best of our ability, his preface, and the parts imme-
diately following it, testing each one of his assertions as we went along, until we finished
with the tirade 3434 of this Jew of his, feigned to have been delivered against Jesus. And in
the second book we met, as we best could, all the charges contained in the invective 3435 of
the said Jew, which were levelled at us who are believers in God through Christ; and now
we enter upon this third division of our discourse, in which our object is to refute the alleg-
ations which he makes in his own person.
He gives it as his opinion, that “the controversy between Jews and Christians is a most
foolish one,” and asserts that “the discussions which we have with each other regarding
Christ differ in no respect from what is called in the proverb, ‘a fight about the shadow of
an ass;’” 3436 and thinks that “there is nothing of importance 3437 in the investigations of
the Jews and Christians: for both believe that it was predicted by the Divine Spirit that one
was to come as a Saviour to the human race, but do not yet agree on the point whether the
person predicted has actually come or not.” For we Christians, indeed, have believed in Jesus,
as He who came according to the predictions of the prophets. But the majority of the Jews
are so far from believing in Him, that those of them who lived at the time of His coming
conspired against Him; and those of the present day, approving of what the Jews of former
times dared to do against Him, speak evil of Him, asserting that it was by means of sorcery
3438 that he passed himself off for Him who was predicted by the prophets as the One who
was to come, and who was called, agreeably to the traditions of the Jews, 3439 the Christ.
3434 δημηγορίας: cf. book i. c. 71.
3435 δημηγορίας: cf. book i. c. 71.
3436 κατὰ τὴν παροιμίαν καλουμένης ὄνου σκιᾶς μάχης. On this proverb, see Zenobius, Centuria Sexta,
adag. 28, and the note of Schottius. Cf. also Suidas, s.v. ὄνου σκιά.— De la Rue.
3437 σεμνόν.
3438 διά τινος γοητείας.
3439 κατὰ τὰ ᾽Ιουδαίων πάτρια.
Book IIIChapter I
1034
Book III