“But God,” he says,
“gave the weakest of terrestrial things a share in the most
honourable names, though not giving them an equal share of dignity, and
to the highest He imparted the names of the lowest, though the natural
inferiority of the latter was not transferred to the former along with
their names.” We quote this in his very words. If they contain
some deep and recondite meaning which has escaped us, let those inform
us who see what is beyond our range of vision—initiated as they
are by him in his esoteric and unspeakable mysteries. But if they admit
of no interpretation beyond what is obvious, I scarcely know which of
the two are more to be pitied, those who say such things or those who
listen to them. To the weakest of terrestrial things, he says, God has
given names in common with the most honourable, though not giving them
an equal share of dignity. Let us examine what is meant by this. The
weakest things, he says, are dignified with the bare name belonging to
the honourable, their nature not corresponding with their name. And
this he states to be the work of the God of truth—to dignify the
worse nature with the worthier appellation! On the other hand, he says
that God applies the less honourable names to things superior in their
nature, the nature of the latter not being carried over to the former
along with the appellation. But that the matter may be made plainer
still, the absurdity shall be shown by actual instances. If any one
should call a man who is esteemed for every virtue, intemperate; or, on
the other hand, a man equally in disrepute for his vices, good and
moral, would sensible people think him of sound mind, or one who had
any regard for truth, reversing, as would be the case, the meanings of
words, and giving them a non-natural signification? I for my part think
not. He speaks, then, of things relating to God, out of all keeping
with our common ideas and with the holy Scriptures. For in matters of
ordinary life it is only those who are unsettled by drink or madness
that go wrong in names, and use them out of their proper meaning,
calling, it may be, a man a dog, or vice versa. But Holy Scripture is
so far from sanctioning such confusion, that we may clearly hear the
voice of prophecy lamenting it. “Woe unto him,” says
Isaiah, “that calls darkness light, and light darkness, that
calls bitter sweet, and sweet bitter Is. v. 20..” Now
what induces Eunomius to apply this absurdity to his God? Let those who
are initiated in his mysteries say what they judge those weakest of
terrestrial things to be, which God has dignified with most honourable
appellations. The weakest of existing things are those animals whose
generation takes place from the corruption of moist elements, as the
most honourable are virtue, and holiness, and whatever else is pleasing
in the sight of God. Are flies, then, and midges, and frogs, and
whatever insects are generated from dung, dignified with the names of
holiness and virtue, so as to be consecrated with honourable names,
though not sharing in such high qualities, as saith Eunomius? But never
as yet have we heard anything like this, that these weak things are
called by high-sounding titles, or that what is great and honourable by
nature is degraded by the name of any one of them. Noah was a righteous
man, saith the Scripture, Abraham was faithful, Moses meek, Daniel
wise, Joseph chaste, Job blameless, David perfect in patience. Let them
say, then, whether all these had their names by contraries; or, to take
the case of those who are unfavourably spoken of, as Nabal the
Carmelite, and Pharaoh the Egyptian, and Abimelech the alien, and all
those who are mentioned for their vices, whether they were dignified
with honourable names by the voice of God. Not so! But God judges and
distinguishes His creatures as they are in nature and truth, not by
names contrary to them, but by such appropriate appellations as may
give the clearest idea of their meaning.