(2) The Eusebians and the Court. Until the
council of Sardica (i.e. a short time after the death of Eusebius of
Nicomedia), the motive power of the reaction proceeded from the
environment of Eusebius, οἱ
περὶ
Εὐσέβιον. It should be
observed once for all that the term ‘Eusebians’ is the later and inexact equivalent of
the last named Greek phrase, which (excepting perhaps p. 436) has
reference to Eusebius of Nicomedia only, and not to his namesake of
Cæsarea. The latter, no doubt, lent his support to the action of
the party, but ought not to suffer in our estimation from the
misfortune of his name. Again, the ‘Eusebians’ are not a
heresy, nor a theological party or school; they are the
‘ring,’ or personal entourage, of one man, a master
of intrigue, who succeeded in combining a very large number of men of
very different opinions in more or less close association for common
ecclesiastical action. The ‘Eusebians’ sensu latiori
are the majority of Asiatic bishops who were in reaction against the
council and its leaders; in the stricter sense the term denotes the
pure Arians like Eusebius, Theognis, and the rest, and those
‘political Arians’ who without settled adherence to Arian
principles, were, for all practical purposes, hand in glove with
Eusebius and his fellows. To the former class emphatically belong
Valens and Ursacius, whose recantation in 347 is the solitary and
insufficient foundation for the sweeping generalisation of Socrates
(ii. 37), that they ‘always inclined to the party in
power,’ and George, the presbyter of Alexandria, afterwards
bishop of the Syrian Laodicea, who, although he went through a phase of
‘conservatism,’ 357–359, began and ended (Gwatkin,
pp. 181–183) as an Arian, pure and simple. Among ‘political
Arians’ of this period Eusebius of Cæsarea is the chief. He
was not, as we have said above, an Arian theologically, yet whatever
allowances may be made for his conduct during this period (D.C.B., ii.
315, 316) it tended all in one direction. But on the whole, political
Arianism is more abundantly exemplified in the Homœans of the next
generation, whose activity begins about the time of the death of
Constans. The Eusebians proper were political indeed εἴ τινες καὶ
ἄλλοι, but their essential Arianism is
the one element of principle about them At the
same time Arius himself and all his fellow Lucianists (unlike the
obscure Secundus and Theonas, and the later generation of Eunomians)
are open to the charge of subserviency at a pinch.. Above
all, the employment of the term ‘Semi-Arians’ as a synonym
for Eusebians, or indeed as a designation of any party at this period,
is to be strongly deprecated. It is the (possibly somewhat misleading,
but reasonable and accepted) term for the younger generation of
convinced ‘conservatives,’ whom we find in the sixth
decade of the century becoming conscious of their essential difference
in principle from the Arians, whether political or pure, and feeling
their way toward fusion with the Nicenes. These are a definite party,
with a definite theological position, to which nothing in the earlier
period exactly corresponds. The Eusebians proper were not semi-,
but real Arians. Eusebius of Cæsarea and the Asiatic
conservatives are the predecessors of the semi-Arians, but their
position is not quite the same. Reserving them for a moment, we must
complete our account of the Eusebians proper. Their nucleus consisted
of the able and influential circle of ‘Lucianists;’ it has
been remarked by an unprejudiced observer that, so far as we know, not
one of them was eminent as a religious character (Harnack, ii.
185); their strength was in fixity of policy and in ecclesiastical
intrigue; and their battery was the imperial court. Within three years
of the Council, Constantine had begun to waver, not in his resolution
to maintain the Nicene Creed, that he never relaxed, but in his
sternness toward its known opponents. His policy was dictated by the
desire for unity: he was made to feel the lurking dissatisfaction of
the bishops of Asia, perhaps as his anger was softened by time he
missed the ability and ready counsel of the extruded bishop of his
residential city. An Arian presbyter (‘Eustathius’ or
‘Eutokius’?), who was a kind of chaplain to Constantia,
sister of Constantine and widow of Licinius, is said to have kept the
subject before the Emperor’s mind after her death (in 328, see
Socr. i. 25). At last, as we have seen, first Eusebius and Theognis
were recalled, then Arius himself was pardoned upon his general
assurance of agreement with the faith of the Synod.