37. Reversing the order, we have given our answer
respecting the state of souls and the resurrection of the flesh; and,
leaving out the opening portions of the letter, we have confined
ourselves to the refutation of this most remarkable treatise. For we
preferred to speak of the things of God rather than of our own wrongs. 1 Sam. ii. 25.“If one man sin against another,
they shall pray for him to the Lord. But if he sin against God, who
shall pray for him?” In these days, on the contrary, we make it
our first business to pursue with undying hate those who have injured us—to those
who blaspheme God we indulgently hold out the hand. John writes to
Bishop Theophilus an apology, of which the introduction runs thus:
“You, indeed, as a man of God, adorned with apostolic grace, have
upon you the care of all the Churches, especially of that which is at
Jerusalem, though you yourself are distracted with countless anxieties
for the Church of God, which is under you.” This is barefaced
adulation, and an attempt to concentrate Laudat faciem, ad
personam principum trahit. Literally, He praises the face (i.e.
the person of Theophilus) and draws him on to act the part of (only fit
for) princes. authority in the hands of an
individual. You, who ask for ecclesiastical rules, and make use of
the Canon 6 says
that the old customs are to hold good, that all Egypt is to be subject
to the authority of the bishop of Alexandria, just as the custom holds
at Rome; and similarly that at Antioch, and in the other churches the
authority of the churches should be preserved to them. Canon 7 says:
“Since custom and ancient tradition has prevailed to cause honour
to be given to the bishop of Ælia (Jerusalem), let him have the
proper results of this honour; saving, however, the proper authority
due to the metropolis” (that is, Cæsarea). canons of the Council of Nicæa,
and claim authority over clerics who belong to another diocese and are This relates to
Paulinianus, who was ordained by Epiphanius, and was then living with
him in Cyprus.actually living with their own bishop,
answer my question, What has Palestine to do with the bishop of
Alexandria? Unless I am deceived, it is decreed in those canons that
Cæsarea is the metropolis of Palestine, and Antioch of the whole
of the East. You ought therefore either to appeal to the bishop of
Cæsarea, with whom you know that we have communion while we
disdain to communicate with you, or, if judgment were to be sought at a
distance, letters ought rather to be addressed to Antioch. But I know
why you were unwilling to send to Cæsarea, or to Antioch. You knew
what to flee from, what to avoid. You preferred to assail with your
complaints ears that were preoccupied rather than pay due honour to
your metropolitan. And I do not say this because I have anything to
blame in the mission itself, except certain partialities which beget
suspicion, but because you ought rather to clear yourself in the actual
presence of your questioners. You begin with the words, “You have
sent a most devoted servant of God, the presbyter Isidore, a man of
influence no less from the dignity of his very gait and dress than from
that of his divine understanding, to heal those whose souls are
grievously sick; would that they had any sense of their illness! A man
of God sends a man of God.” No difference is made between a
priest and a bishop; the same dignity belongs to the sender and the
sent; this is lame enough; the ship, as the saying goes, is wrecked in
harbour. That Isidore, whom you extol to the sky by your praises, lies
under the same imputation of heresy Theophilus, whose
sympathies had suddenly changed, turned violently against Isidore, who
had previously been his confidential friend, accused him of Origenism,
and, on his taking refuge with Chrysostom at Constantinople, pursued
both him and Chrysostom with unrelenting animosity. at
Alexandria as you at Jerusalem; wherefore he appears to have come to
you not as an envoy, but as a confederate. Besides, the letters in his
own handwriting, which, three months before the sending of the embassy,
had been sent to us Reading
portantes errorem. Another reading is, “Through the error
of the bearer.” through an
error in the address, were delivered to the presbyter Vincentius, and
to this day they are in his keeping. In these letters the writer
encourages the leader of his army John, to whom
the letters were really written. to plant
his foot firmly upon the rock of the faith, and not to be terrified by
our Jeremiads. He promises, before we had any suspicion of his mission,
that he will come to Jerusalem, and that on his arrival the ranks of
his adversaries will be instantly crushed. And amongst the rest he uses
these words: “As smoke vanishes in the air, and wax melts beside
the fire, so shall they be scattered who are for ever resisting the
faith of the Church, and are now through simple men endeavouring to
disturb that faith.”