3. For if a bad will ought to be always left to its own freedom, why were the disobedient
and murmuring Israelites restrained from evil by such severe chastisements, and compelled
to come into the land of promise? If a bad will ought always to be left to its own freedom,
why was Paul not left to the free use of that most perverted will with which he persecuted
the Church? Why was he thrown to the ground that he might be blinded, and struck blind
that he might be changed, and changed that he might be sent as an apostle, and sent that
he might suffer for the truth’s sake such wrongs as he had inflicted on others when he was
in error? If a bad will ought always to be left to its own freedom, why is a father instructed
in Holy Scripture not only to correct an obstinate son by words of rebuke, but also to beat
his sides, in order that, being compelled and subdued, he may be guided to good conduct?2813
545
For which reason Solomon also says: “Thou shalt beat him with the rod, and shalt deliver
his soul from hell.”2814 If a bad will ought always to be left to its own freedom, why are
negligent pastors reproved? and why is it said to them, “Ye have not brought back the
wandering sheep, ye have not sought the perishing”?2815 You also are sheep belonging to
Christ, you bear the Lord’s mark in the sacrament which you have received, but you are
wandering and perishing. Let us not, therefore, incur your displeasure because we bring
back the wandering and seek the perishing; for it is better for us to obey the will of the Lord,
who charges us to compel you to return to His fold, than to yield consent to the will of the
wandering sheep, so as to leave you to perish. Say not, therefore, what I hear that you are
constantly saying, “I wish thus to wander; I wish thus to perish;” for it is better that we
should so far as is in our power absolutely refuse to allow you to wander and perish.
4. When you threw yourself the other day into a well, in order to bring death upon
yourself, you did so no doubt with your free will. But how cruel the servants of God would
have been if they had left you to the fruits of this bad will, and had not delivered you from
that death! Who would not have justly blamed them? Who would not have justly denounced
them as inhuman? And yet you, with your own free will, threw yourself into the water that
you might be drowned. They took you against your will out of the water, that you might
not be drowned. You acted according to your own will, but with a view to your destruction;
they dealt with you against your will, but in order to your preservation. If, therefore, mere
bodily safety behoves to be so guarded that it is the duty of those who love their neighhour
to preserve him even against his own will from harm, how much more is this duty binding
in regard to that spiritual health in the loss of which the consequence to be dreaded is
eternal death! At the same time let me remark, that in that death which you wished to bring
upon yourself you would have died not for time only but for eternity, because even though
2813 Eccles. xxx. 12.
2814 Prov. xxiii. 14.
2815 Ezek. xxxiv. 4.
1155
To Donatus