A. And I to speak to deaf ears. I will therefore reply
to your argument. Made up of soul and body, we have the nature of both
substances. As the body is said to be healthy if it is troubled with no
weakness, so the soul is free from fault if it is unshaken and
undisturbed. And yet, although the body may be healthy, sound, and
active, with all the faculties in their full vigour, yet it suffers
much from infirmities at more or less frequent intervals, and, however
strong it may be, is sometimes distressed by various humours; so the
soul, bearing the onset of thoughts and agitations, even though it
escape shipwreck, does not sail without danger, and remembering its
weakness, is always anxious about death, according as it is written, Ps. lxxxix. 48.“What man is he that shall
live and not see death?”—death, which threatens all mortal
men, not through the decay of nature, but through the death of sin,
according to the prophet’s words, Ezek. xviii. 4. “The soul that sinneth, it
shall die.” Besides, we know that Enoch and Elias have not yet
seen this death which is common to man and the brutes. Show me a body
which is never sick, or which after sickness is ever safe and sound,
and I will show you a soul which
never sinned, and after acquiring virtues will never again sin. The
thing is impossible, and all the more when we remember that vice
borders on virtue, and that, if you deviate ever so little, you will
either go astray or fall over a precipice. How small is the interval
between obstinacy and perseverance, miserliness and frugality,
liberality and extravagance, wisdom and craft, intrepidity and
rashness, caution and timidity! some of which are classed as good,
others as bad. And the same applies to bodies. If you take precautions
against biliousness, the phlegm increases. If you dry up the humours
too quickly, the blood becomes heated and vitiated with bile, and a
sallow hue spreads over the countenance. Without question, however much
we may exercise all the care of the physician, and regulate our diet,
and be free from indigestion and whatever fosters disease, the causes
of which are in some cases hidden from us and known to God alone, we
shiver with cold, or burn with fever, or howl with colic, and implore
the help of the true physician, our Saviour, and S. Matt. viii. 25.say with the Apostles, “Master,
save us, we perish.”