Would not the defenders of the opposite belief say this: that the body, being composite,
must necessarily be resolved into that of which it is composed? And when the coalition of
elements in the body ceases, each of those elements naturally gravitates towards its kindred
element with the irresistible bias of like to like; the heat in us will thus unite with heat, the
earthy with the solid, and each of the other elements also will pass towards its like. Where,
then, will the soul be after that? If one affirm that it is in those elements, one will be obliged
to admit that it is identical with them, for this fusion could not possibly take place between
two things of different natures. But this being granted, the soul must necessarily be viewed
as a complex thing, fused as it is with qualities so opposite. But the complex is not simple,
431
but must be classed with the composite, and the composite is necessarily dissoluble; and
dissolution means the destruction of the compound; and the destructible is not immortal,
else the flesh itself, resolvable as it is into its constituent elements, might so be called immor-
tal. If, on the other hand, the soul is something other than these elements, where can our
reason suggest a place for it to be, when it is thus, by virtue of its alien nature, not to be
discovered in those elements, and there is no other place in the world, either, where it may
continue, in harmony with its own peculiar character, to exist? But, if a thing can be found
nowhere, plainly it has no existence.
The Teacher sighed gently at these words of mine, and then said; Maybe these were the
objections, or such as these, that the Stoics and Epicureans collected at Athens made in answer
to the Apostle. I hear that Epicurus carried his theories in this very direction. The framework
of things was to his mind a fortuitous1752 and mechanical affair, without a Providence
penetrating its operations; and, as a piece with this, he thought that human life was like a
bubble, existing only as long as the breath within was held in by the enveloping substance1753,
a butt set up to be shot at. All the mss. but not the Paris Editions, have the article before ἀντιπιπτότων: but it is
not absolutely necessary, for Gregory not unfrequently omits it before participles, when his meaning is general,
i.e. “Everything that,” &c.
1752 ὡς τυχαία, κ.τ.λ. It is better to connect this directly with Epicurus himself, than to refer it, by bracketing
the preceding sentence (with Oehler), to his followers. Macrina infers from the opinions known to her of Epi-
curus, what he must have said about the human soul: i.e. that it was a bubble; and then what his followers
probably said. There is no evidence that Epicurus used this actual figure: still Gregory may be recording his very
words.—Lucian (Charon, 68) enlarges on such a simile: and his ὠκύμορον φύσημα, as a description of man, is
reproduced by Gregory himself in Orat. de Beatitud. p. 768 D.
1753 τῷ περιέχοντι. Sifanus takes this of the surrounding atmosphere. So also Krabinger, “aere circumfuso,”
just as above (182 A.) it does certainly mean the air, and Wolf quotes a passage to that effect from Marcus Ant-
oninus and the present instance also. Still there is no reason that it should not here mean the body of the man,
which is as it were a case retentive of the vital breath within; and the sense seems to require it. As to the construc-
tion, although πομφόλυξ is sometimes masculine in later Greek, yet it is much more likely that περιταθέντος
802
On the Soul and the Resurrection.