74. After this again certain others came; and
these were men who were deemed wise among the Greeks, and they asked
him a reason for our faith in Christ. But when they attempted to
dispute concerning the preaching of the divine Cross and meant to mock,
Antony stopped for a little, and first pitying their ignorance, said,
through an interpreter, who could skilfully interpret his words,
‘Which is more beautiful, to confess the Cross or to attribute to
those whom you call gods adultery and the seduction of boys? For that
which is chosen by us is a sign of courage and a sure token of the
contempt of death, while yours are the passions of licentiousness.
Next, which is better, to say that the Word of God was not changed,
but, being the same, He took a human body for the salvation and
well-being of man, that having shared in human birth He might make man
partake in the divine and spiritual nature Cf.
de Incar. 54. 3; 2 Pet. i. 4.;
or to liken the divine to senseless animals and consequently to worship
four-footed beasts, creeping things and the likenesses of men? For
these things, are the objects of reverence of you wise men. But how do
you dare to mock us, who say that Christ has appeared as man, seeing
that you, bringing the soul from heaven, assert that it has strayed and
fallen from the vault of the sky into body Cf.
Plat. Phædr. 274 B: but the resemblances is not close and
the relation of this passage to the Phædrus is probably mediate. I
cannot see that the doctrine referred to here is necessarily different
from that of Plotinus (Enn. IV. iii. 15).?
And would that you had said that it had fallen into human body alone,
and not asserted that it passes and changes into four-footed beasts and
creeping things. For our faith declares that the coming of Christ was
for the salvation of men. But you err because you speak of soul as not
generated. And we, considering the power and loving-kindness of
Providence, think that the coming of Christ in the flesh was not
impossible with God. But you, although calling the soul the likeness of
Mind Plotinus (Enn. V. i. 3) taught that the soul was, as it
were, an image of Mind, as the uttered word is of the word in the soul
(cf. Philo. Vit. Mos. iii. 13)., connect it with falls and feign in your myths that it is changeable, and
consequently introduce the idea that Mind itself is changeable by
reason of the soul. For whatever is the nature of a likeness, such
necessarily is the nature of that of which it is a likeness. But
whenever you think such a thought concerning Mind, remember that you
blaspheme even the Father of Mind Himself It is
certainly startling to find Antony, ignorant of Greek and of letters,
reasoning with philosophers upon the doctrines of Neoplatonism. His
whole life, excepting two short visits to Alexandria, had been spent
out of ear-shot of such discussions. Yet it is not easy to say exactly
how much a man of strong mind and retentive memory may have picked up
from the conversation of those who visited him upon subjects so widely
discussed as these speculations were..