34. But, agreeing with you that in all these stories stags are spoken of instead of
Iphigenias, yet, how are you sure, when you either explain or unfold these allegories, that
you give the same explanations or have the same ideas which were entertained by the writers
themselves in the silence of their thoughts, but expressed by words not adapted4494 to what
was meant, but to something else? You say that the falling of rain into the bosom of the
earth was spoken of as the union of Jupiter and Ceres; another may both devise with greater
subtlety, and conjecture with some probability, something else; a third, a fourth may do the
same; and as the characteristics of the minds of the thinkers show themselves, so each thing
may be explained in an infinite number of ways. For since all that allegory, as it is called, is
taken from narratives expressly made obscure,4495 and has no certain limit within which
the meaning of the story,4496 as it is called, should be firmly fixed and unchangeable, it is
open to every one to put the meaning into it which he pleases, and to assert that that has
been adopted4497 to which his thoughts and surmises4498 led him. But this being the case,
503
how can you obtain certainty from what is doubtful, and attach one sense only to an expres-
sion which you see to be explained in innumerable different ways?4499
4494 Lit., “proper.”
4495 Lit., “from shut-up things.”
4496 Rei.
4497 Lit., “placed.”
4498 Lit., “his suspicion and conjectural (perhaps “probable”) inference.”
4499 Lit., “to be deduced with variety of expositions through numberless ways.”
Chapter XXXIV.
1212
Chapter XXXIV.