Chapter
XXIII.—Simeon’s “Sign that Should Be
Contradicted,” Applied to the Heretical Gainsaying of the True
Birth of Christ. One of the Heretics’ Paradoxes Turned in Support
of Catholic Truth.
We acknowledge, however, that the prophetic
declaration of Simeon is fulfilled, which he spoke over the
recently-born Saviour:
7250
“Behold, this
child
is set for the fall and rising again of many in Israel,
and for a sign that shall be spoken against.”
7251
The sign (here meant) is that of the birth
of Christ, according to Isaiah: “Therefore the Lord Himself shall
give you
a sign
: behold, a virgin shall conceive and bear a
son.”
7252
We discover, then,
what the sign is which is to be spoken against—the conception and
the parturition of the Virgin Mary, concerning which these
sophists
7253
say: “She a
virgin and yet not a virgin bare, and yet did not bear;” just as
if such language, if indeed it must be uttered, would not be more
suitable even for ourselves to use! For “she bare,” because
she produced offspring of her own flesh and “yet she did not
bear,” since she produced Him not from a husband’s seed;
she was “a virgin,” so far as (abstinence) from a husband
went, and “yet not a virgin,” as regards her bearing a
child.
There is not, however, that parity of reasoning which the
heretics affect: in other words
it does not follow that for the
reason “she did not bear,”
7254
she who was “not a virgin” was “yet a virgin,”
even because she became a mother without any fruit of her own womb. But
with us there is no equivocation, nothing twisted into a double
sense.
7255
Light is light; and
darkness, darkness; yea is yea; and nay, nay; “whatsoever is more
than these cometh of evil.”
7256
She who bare
(really) bare; and although she was a virgin when she conceived, she
was a wife
7257
when she brought
forth
her son
. Now, as a wife, she was under the very law of
“opening the womb,”
7258
wherein it was
quite immaterial whether the birth of the male was by virtue of a
husband’s co-operation or not;
7259
it was the
same sex
7260
that opened her
womb. Indeed, hers is the womb on account of which it is written of
others also: “Every male that openeth the womb shall be called
holy to the Lord.”
7261
For who is really
holy but the Son of God? Who properly opened the womb but He who opened
a closed one
?
7262
But it is marriage
which opens the womb in all cases.
The virgin’s womb
,
therefore, was especially
7263
opened, because it
was especially closed. Indeed
7264
she ought
rather to be called not a virgin than a virgin, becoming a mother at a
leap, as it were, before she was a wife. And what must be said
more on this point? Since it was in this sense that the apostle
declared that the Son of God was born not of a virgin, but “of a
woman,” he in that statement recognised the condition of the
“opened womb” which ensues in marriage.
7265
We read in Ezekiel of “a
heifer
7266
which brought
forth, and still did not bring forth.” Now, see whether it was
not in view of your own future contentions about the womb of Mary, that
even then the Holy Ghost set His mark upon you in this passage;
otherwise
7267
He would not,
contrary to His usual simplicity of style (in this prophet), have
uttered a sentence of such doubtful import,
especially
when
Isaiah says, “She shall conceive and bear a son.”
7268
7250
Literally,
“Lord.”
7251
Luke ii. 34
.
7252
Isa. vii. 14
.
7253
Academici isti:
“this school of theirs.”
7254
i.e. “Because
she produced not her son from her husband’s seed.”
7255
Defensionem.
7256
Matt. v. 37
.
7257
Nupsit.
7258
Nupsit ipsa patefacti
corporis lege.
7259
De vi masculi admissi
an emissi.
7260
i.e. “The
male.”
7261
Ex. xiii. 2; Luke ii. 23
.
7262
Clausam: i.e. a
virgin’s.
7263
Magis.
7264
Utique.
7265
Nuptialem
passionem.
7266
Epiphanius
(
Hær.
xxx. 30) quotes from the apocryphal Ezekiel this
passage:
Τέξεται ἡ
δάμαλις, καὶ
ἐροῦσιν—οὐ
τέτοκεν
. So Clem. Alex.
Stromata
, vii. Oehler.
7267
Ceterum.
7268
Isa. vii. 14
.