d. The famous discussion between the African
bishops and the Bishop of Rome, on the subject of appeals to Rome,
gives us a very important testimony on the true number of the Nicene
canons. The presbyter Apiarius of Sicca in Africa, having been
deposed for many crimes, appealed to Rome. Pope Zosimus
(417–418) took the appeal into consideration, sent legates to
Africa; and to prove that he had the right to act thus, he quoted a
canon of the Council of Nicæa, containing these words:
“When a bishop thinks he has been unjustly deposed by his
colleagues he may appeal to Rome, and the Roman bishop shall have the
business decided by judices in partibus.” The canon
quoted by the Pope does not belong to the Council of Nicæa, as he
affirmed; it was the fifth canon of the Council of Sardica (the seventh
in the Latin version). What explains the error of Zosimus is that
in the ancient copies the canons of Nicæa and Sardica are written
consecutively, with the same figures, and under the common title of
canons of the Council of Nicæa; and Zosimus might optima
fide fall into an error—which he shared with Greek authors,
his contemporaries, who also mixed the canons of Nicæa with those
of Sardica. The African bishops, not finding the canon quoted by
the Pope either in their Greek or in their Latin copies, in vain
consulted also the copy which Bishop Cecilian, who had himself been
present at the Council of Nicæa, had brought to Carthage.
The legates of the Pope then declared that they did not rely upon these
copies, and they agreed to send to Alexandria and to Constantinople to
ask the patriarchs of these two cities for authentic copies of the
canons of the Council of Nicæa. The African bishops desired
in their turn that Pope Boniface should take the same step (Pope
Zosimus had died meanwhile in 418)—that he should ask for copies
from the Archbishops of Constantinople, Alexandria, and Antioch.
Cyril of Alexandria and Atticus of Constantinople, indeed, sent exact
and faithful copies of the Creed and canons of Nicæa; and two
learned men of Constantinople, Theilo and Thearistus, even translated
these canons into Latin. Their translation has been preserved to
us in the acts of the sixth Council of Carthage, and it contains only
the twenty ordinary canons. It might be thought at first sight
that it contained twenty-one canons; but on closer consideration we
see, as Hardouin has proved, that this twenty-first article is nothing
but an historical notice appended to the Nicene canons by the Fathers
of Carthage. It is conceived in these terms: “After
the bishops had decreed these rules at Nicæa, and after the holy
Council had decided what was the ancient rule for the celebration of
Easter, peace and unity of faith were re-established between the East
and the West. This is what we (the African bishops) have thought
it right to add according to the history of the Church.”