their sinfulness. Those would be strange chastisements from the hand of a wise and good
Father, which are wholly for nothing; especially such severe chastisements, as to break the
child’s bones, when at the same time the father does not suppose any guilt, fault, or offense,
in any respect, belonging to the child; but it is chastised in this terrible manner, only for
fear that it will be faulty hereafter. I say, these would be a strange sort of chastisements; yea,
though he should be able to make it up to the child afterwards. Dr. T. speaks of representa-
tions made by the whole current of Scripture; I am certain, it is not agreeable to the current
of Scripture, to represent divine fatherly chastisements after this manner. It is true, the
175
Scripture supposes such chastenings to be the fruit of God’s goodness; yet at the same time
it evermore represents them as being for the sin of the subject, and as evidences of the divine
displeasure for its sinfulness. Thus the apostle (1 Cor. xi. 30-32. ) speaks of God chastening
his people by mortal sickness, for their good, that they might not be condemned with the
world, and yet signifies that it was for their sin; for this causemany are weak and sickly among
you, and many sleep: that is, for the profaneness and sinful disorder before mentioned. So
Elihu (Job xxxiii. 16, &c.) speaks of the same chastening by sickness, as for men’s good; to
withdraw man from his sinful purpose, and to hide pride from man, and keep back his soul
from the pit; that therefore God chastens man with pain on his bed, and the multitude of his
bones with strong pain. But these chastenings are for his sins, as appears by what follows;
(Job xxxiii. 28.) Where it is observed, that when God by this means has brought men to repent,
and humbly confess their sins, he delivers them. Again, the same Elihu, speaking of the un-
failing love of God to the righteous, even when he chastens them, and they are bound in fetters,
and holden in cords of affliction (Job xxxvi. 7, &c.) yet speaks of these chastenings as being
for their sins ( ver. 9.) “Then he showeth them their work, and their transgressions, that
they have exceeded.” So David (Psal. xxx) speaks of God’s chastening by some afflictions,
as being for his good, and issuing joyfully; and yet being the fruit of God’s anger for his sin
(Psal. xxx. 5.) God’s anger endureth but for a moment, &c. (Compare Psal. cxix. 67, 71, 75.)
God’s fatherly chastisements are spoken of as being for sin. (2 Sam. vii. 14, 15.) “I will be
his father, and he shall be my son. If he commit iniquity, I will chasten him with the rod of
men, and with the stripes of the children of men; but my mercy shall not depart away from
him.” So the prophet Jeremiah speaks of the great affliction that God’s people suffered in
the time of the captivity, as being for their good. (Lam. iii. 25, &c.) But yet these chastisements
are spoken of as being for their SIN, (see especially Lam. iii. 39, 40.) So Christ says, Rev. iii.
19.“As many as I love, I rebuke and chasten.” But the words following show, that these
chastenings from love are for sin that should be repented of: “Be zealous therefore, and re-
pent.” And though Christ tells us, they are blessed that are persecuted for righteousness’
sake, and have reason to rejoice and be exceeding glad; yet even the persecutions of God’s
people, as ordered in divine providence, are spoken of as divine chastenings for sin, like the
just corrections of a father, when the children deserve them, Heb. xii. The apostle there
1013
CHAPTER II. Arguments from universal Mortality.