ST. ANDREWS UNIVERSITY
traitor ; it is a long step from the godly elder of the Westmin-
ster Assembly to the tyrannous Commissioner who made an
Episcopalian king supreme " in poor old Scotland." " Cart-
loads of oaths " were nothing to him beside the sweets of
power, and he did not hesitate to pass a " clanking act "
against the Covenanters. And yet he was a good friend to
learning, and in some ways no bad friend to Scotland either.
The difficulties of his position are obvious ; and he certainly
tried hard by his policy of " Indulgence " to stand between
the Presbyterians and the persecution of the intolerant Prelatists.
It was only when all compromise was refused that he resolved
upon compulsion, the more excusably in that, since troops were
few, it was necessary to check disaffection at the very outset.
The simple fact is that he was entrusted with the execution
of a policy of which he did not approve, and that, until his
second wife became a kind of second Commissioner, he worked
hard for a settlement. Had he not been at the head of affairs
Scotland might have found a worse ruler ; yet for mere love of
power he stayed in office and carried out a system which he
believed to be thoroughly bad.
Presbyterian and Prelatist champions, all are sons of the
same mother, and to-day history would be tolerant and just in
judgment. Sharp certainly does appear to have been rather
a despicable character. Claverhouse was brave, Mackenzie
learned, and it is unnecessary to believe that either took
pleasure in the misery which they found themselves inflicting.
Yet all stand condemned as the instruments of a government
which deliberately ignored the earnest wishes of its subjects.
The extreme Covenanters, it is true, were unreasonable and
intolerant, but with that party as a whole lie the sympathies
of the majority of Scotsmen. The Episcopal settlement which
they were asked to accept was mild in the extreme, almost
Presbyterian, but the principle involved was great. Why
88