To that church, and to its
illustrious bishop, Theodoret naturally turned in his hour of need. He
implored his friend Anatolius to get him permission to plead his own
cause in person in the West, or if not to let him retire to his old
home at Nicerte. Ep.
CXIX. The latter alternative was conceded. In
this retreat he received many proofs of the affectionate regard of his
friends and offers of more practical help than his modest necessities
demanded. Ep.
CXXIII. Thence products of his facile pen travelled
far and wide. The whole series of letters written at this period gives
touching testimony to the gentle and forgiving spirit of the sorely
tried bishop. There is nothing of the bitterness and fierce anger which
appear sometimes in the earlier controversy with Cyril. He is refined,
not soured, by adversity, and, though he never approached nearer to
canonization than the acquisition of the inferior title of Blessed, he
appears in these dark days as no unworthy specimen of the suffering
saint. Epp.
CXIII. to CXXXIII. and CLXXXI. The chief interest of these letters is in
truth moral, spiritual and theological. This, however, has been
obscured by the ecclesiastical interest which has been given them by
the unwarranted attempt to represent Theodoret’s letter to Leo as
an “appeal” to the see of Rome in the later and technical
sense of the word. Whether St. Hilary of Arles ever did or did not give
the lie to his short life of strenuous protest against the growing
aggrandizement of the see of Rome, there is no doubt that before his
death at the age of 41 in 449 his suffragans had been released by Leo
from allegiance to a Metropolitan disobedient to the Roman chair, and
that Valentinian had issued an edict confirming Leo’s claims and
making the authority of the Bishop of Rome supreme in the West. Cf.
Milman Lat. Christ. Book ii. Chap. iv; Const. Valentin. iii Aug. apud
S. Leon. op. epist. xi. It would be useful to maintainers of the
Roman supremacy if they could adduce instances of any assertion or
acceptance of similar authority in the East. So it has been said that
Theodoret appealed to the Pope. Garnerius, the Jesuit, in his dissertation on the life of
Theodoret writes: “When Theodoret got news of his deposition he
determined to send envoys to the apostolic see, that is to the head of
all the churches in the world, to plead his cause before the righteous
judgment seat of St. Leo,” and in his summary of his own chapter
he says “Theodoret appeals to the apostolic
see.” In a sense this is
of course perfectly true. Theodoret did appeal to the Pope. But the
whole superstructure of papal supremacy, so far as Theodoret is
concerned, is really based upon a poor paronomasia. The bishop of Cyrus
“appealed” to the bishop of Rome as any bishop believing
himself to lie under an unjust sentence might appeal to any other
bishop, and as Theodoret did appeal to other bishops. It is quite true
that the church of Rome had many claims to honour and regard, as
Theodoret himself felicitously and opportunely points out, and that the
present occupant of its throne was a man of unblemished orthodoxy and
of commanding personal dignity. But to recognise these facts is a long
way from admitting that this very dignified see had either de
facto or de jure any coercive jurisdiction over the
Metropolitans of Alexandria or of Hierapolis, to the latter of whom
Cyrus was subordinate. Theodoret himself quotes the crucial passage in
St. Matthew’s gospel Matt. xvi. 18 apparently without
any idea that the “Petra” means all the successors of the
“Petrus.” Ep.
CXLVI. What Theodoret asked
from Leo was not the sentence of a superior but the sympathy and
support of an influential brother. What made it so peculiarly important
that he should gain the ear and the approval of Leo was that Rome had
been wholly unconcerned in the intrigue which condemned him. He could
have had no more idea of papal authority in the later
ultramontane sense than he could of the decrees of the Vatican
Council. Bound as he was to do his utmost to vindicate not so much his
own position and doctrinal soundness, as the truth now trampled on by
the combined factions of Alexandria and the court, he naturally turned
to Leo as alike the most respected and most independent bishop of his
age. cf.
Glubokowski. pp. 237, 239. Du Pin. iv. 83. Cardinal Newman, in his very
bright and sympathetic sketch of Theodoret, (Hist. Sketches ii. 308 ed.
1891) writes the following remarkable sentence. “This, at least,
he has in common with St. Chrysostom that both of them were deprived of
their episcopal rank by a council, both appealed to the holy see, and
by the holy see both were cleared and restored to their ecclesiastical
dignities.” It would be difficult in the compass of so short a
sentence to combine more statements so completely misleading. To say
that Chrysostom and Theodoret both appealed to the “holy
see” is as much an anachronism as to say that they appealed to
the Court of the Vatican or to the Dome of St. Peter’s. In their
day there was no holy see, that is to say, κατ᾽
ἐξοχήν. All
sees were holy sees, just as all bishops were styled your holiness.
Rome, it is true, was the only apostolical see in the West, but it was
not the only apostolical see, and whatever official precedence it could
claim over Antioch, Jerusalem, and Alexandria, was due to its being the
see of the old imperial capital, a precedence expressly ordered at
Chalcedon to be shared with the new Rome on the Bosphorus. As to the
“appeal,” we have seen what it meant in the case of
Theodoret. It meant the same in the case of Chrysostom. Cut to the
quick at the cruel and brutal treatment of his friends after his
banishment from Constantinople in the summer of 404 he pleaded his
cause in letters sent as well to Venerius of Milan and Chromatius of
Aquileia as to Innocent of Rome. Innocent very properly espoused his
cause, declared his deposition void, and did his best to move Honorius
to move Arcadius to convoke a council. The cruel story of the long
martyrdom of bitter exile and the death in the lonely chapel at Comana
is a terrible satire on the restoration to ecclesiastical dignities.
The unwary reader of “the historical sketch” might imagine
the famous John of the mouth of gold brought back in triumph to
Constantinople by the authority of the pope in 404 as he had been by
the enthusiasm of his flock in 403, and Arcadius and Eudoxia cowering
before the power of Holy Church like Henry IV. at Canossa in 1077. The
true picture of the three years of agony which preceded the old
man’s passage to the better world in 407 is a painful contrast to
contemplate (Pallad. Dial. 1–3. Theodoret V. 34. Sozomen viii.
26, 27, 28.) Of Theodoret’s restoration to “ecclesiastical
dignity,” and Leo’s part in it, we shall see further
on.