24. For first of all, as to their first question,
which is such as this, how dull and vague it is! they do not explain
who it is they ask about, so as to allow of an answer, but they say
abstractedly, ‘He who is,’ ‘him who is not.’
Who then ‘is,’ and what ‘are not,’ O Arians? or
who ‘is,’ and who ‘is not?’ what are said
‘to be,’ what ‘not to be?’ for He that is, can
make things which are not, and which are, and which were before. For
instance, carpenter, and goldsmith, and potter, each, according to his
own art, works upon materials previously existing, making what vessels
he pleases; and the God of all Himself, having taken the dust of the
earth existing and already brought to be, fashions man; that very
earth, however, whereas it was not once, He has at one time made by His
own Word. If then this is the meaning of their question, the creature
on the one hand plainly was not before its origination, and men, on the
other, work the existing material; and thus their reasoning is
inconsequent, since both ‘what is’ becomes, and ‘what
is not’ becomes, as these instances shew. But if they speak
concerning God and His Word, let them complete their question and then
ask, Was the God, ‘who is,’ ever without Reason? and,
whereas He is Light, was He ray-less? or was He always Father of the
Word? Or again in this manner. Has the Father ‘who is’ made
the Word ‘who is not,’ or has He ever with Him His Word, as
the proper offspring of His substance? This will shew them that they do
but presume and venture on sophisms about God and Him who is from Him.
Who indeed can bear to hear them say that God was ever without Reason?
this is what they fall into a second time, though endeavouring in vain
to escape it and to hide it with their sophisms. Nay, one would fain
not hear them disputing at all, that God was not always Father, but became so afterwards (which is
necessary for their fantasy, that His Word once was not), considering
the number of the proofs already adduced against them; while John
besides says, ‘The Word was John i. 1.,’ and
Paul again writes, ‘Who being the brightness of His glory Heb. i. 3.,’ and, ‘Who is over all, God
blessed for ever. Amen Rom. ix. 5..’