the words of one plainly deliberating, not blindly subscribing out of obedience. The rest
say to the same effect: “It agrees, and I subscribe.” Many plainly and expressly, “It agrees,
and I therefore subscribe.” Some add, “It agrees, and I subscribe, as it is correct.” Others,
“I am sure that it agrees.” Others, “As it is concordant, and has the same aim, we embrace
it, and subscribe.” Others, “This is the faith we have long held: this we hold: in this we
were baptized: in this we baptize.” Others, and a great part, “As I see, as I feel, as I have
proved, as I find that it agrees, I subscribe.” Others, “As I am persuaded, instructed, informed,
245
that all agrees, I subscribe.” Many set forth their difficulties, mostly arising from a foreign
language; others from the subject matter, saying, that they had heard the letter, “and in very
many points were assured it was right; some few words stood in their way, which seemed
to point at a certain division in the person of Christ.” They add, that they had been informed
by Paschasinus and the Legates “that there is no division, but one Christ; therefore,” they
say, “we agree and subscribe.” Others after mentioning what Paschasinus and Lucentius
had said, thus conclude: “By this we have been satisfied and, considering that it agrees in
all things with the holy Fathers, we agree and subscribe.” Where the Illyrian bishops, and
others who before that examination had expressed their acclamations to the letter, again
cry out, “We all say the same thing, and agree with this.” So that, indeed, it is evident that,
in the council itself, and before it their agreement is based on this that, after weighing the
matter, they considered, they judged, they were persuaded, that all agreed with the Fathers,
and perceived that the common faith of all and each had been set forth by Leo. This is that
examination of Leo’s letter, synodically made at Chalcedon, and placed among the acts.
(Gallia Orthod., LIX.)
Nor did Anatolius and the other bishops receive it, until they had deliberated, and found
that Leo’s letter agreed with the preceding councils.
(Gallia Orthod., LX.)
But here a singular discussion arises between the eminent Cardinals Bellarmine and
Baronius. The latter, and with him a large number of our theologians, recognize the letter
of Leo as the Type and Rule of faith, by which all Churches were bound: but Bellarmine,
alarmed at the examination which he could not deny, answers thus: “Leo had sent his letter
to the council, not as containing his final and definitive sentence, but as an instruction, as-
sisted by which the bishops might form a better judgment.” But, most eminent man, allow
me to say that Leo, upon the appeal of Eutyches, and at the demand of Flavian, composed
this letter for a summary of the faith, and sent it to every Church in all parts, when as yet
no one thought about a council. Therefore it was not an instruction to the council which
he provided, but an Apostolic sentence which he put forth. The fact is that out of this strait
there was no other escape: Baronius will not allow that a letter, confirmed by so great an
authority of the Apostolic See, should be attributed to any other power but that which is
supreme and indefectible: Bellarmine will not take that to emanate from the supreme and
457
General Introduction.