His education on the religious side was in the Nicene
faith as professed by the Catholic Church in the East, to which the
monks remained, not always thoughtfully faithful, in all that stormy
period. As Sozomen says, the people were unable to follow the
refinements of theological discussion, and took their cue from those
whose lives seemed better than that of the ordinary clergy. He had,
however, no close drill in the arguments pro and con, judging from his
own declarations of inability to follow the various aspects of Arian
discussion. After citing the letter of Gregory Nazianzen to Nectarius,
in which the distinctive features of the heresy of Apolinarius are
given, he supplements: “What I have said, may, I think, suffice
to show the nature of the sentiments maintained by Apolinarius and
Eunomius. If any one desire more detailed information, I can only refer
him to the works on the subject, written either by them or by others,
concerning these men. I do not profess easily to understand or to
expound these matters” (ἐπεὶ ἐμοὶ
οὔτε
συνιέναι τὰ
τοιαῦτα, οὔτε
μεταφράζειν
εὐπετές, vi. 27). And when
he enumerates the causes of rupture among the Eunomians, “I
should be prolix were I to enter into further particulars; and indeed
the subject would be by no means an easy one to me, since I have no
such dialectic skill” (ἐπεὶ μηδὲ
ἐμπείρως ἔχω
τῶν τοιούτων
διαλέξεων, vii.
17). It would seem, then, that his logical training had not been of a
very deep quality, and yet it must be said that such definitions and
arguments as he does state in the history of controversy are orderly
and lucid. Metaphysics also seems to have had no large place in his
earlier studies; but he certainly did become familiar with its later
theological terms and distinctions, and he draws a clear line between
the various contestants who warred for and against consubstantiality.
His reading also covered some philosophical speculations, as one
gathers from a sentence in v. 6, “For it is not true, as some
assert, that as is the body, so is the soul.” He probably also
early learned to distinguish between ontology and ethics, by the
practical lines drawn between the clerical disputant and the monastic
philosopher. A sentence in his history of Meletius, bishop of Antioch
(iv. 28), emphasizes this difference as we seldom find it in early
Christian literature: “In his first discourse he confines himself
to instructing the people in what we call ethics (τοὺς
καλουμένους
ἠθικοὺς
λόγους), and then openly declared
the Son to be of the same substance as the Father.”