fectly keeping the right path, it is a thing much more worthy of admiration and praise to
receive admonition meekly, than to admonish a transgressor boldly. On that occasion,
therefore, Paul was to be praised for upright courage, Peter was to be praised for holy humil-
ity; and so far as my judgment enables me to form an opinion, this ought rather to have
been asserted in answer to the calumnies of Porphyry, than further occasion given to him
for finding fault, by putting it in his power to bring against Christians this much more
damaging accusation, that either in writing their letters or in complying with the ordinances
of God they practised deceit.
Chap. III.
23. You call upon me to bring forward the name of even one whose opinion I have fol-
lowed in this matter, and at the same time you have quoted the names of many who have
held before you the opinion which you defend.2054 You also say that if I censure you for an
error in this, you beg to be allowed to remain in error in company with such great men. I
have not read their writings; but although they are only six or seven in all, you have yourself
impugned the authority of four of them. For as to the Laodicean author,2055 whose name
you do not give, you say that he has lately forsaken the Church; Alexander you describe as
a heretic of old standing; and as to Origen and Didymus, I read in some of your more recent
358
works, censure passed on their opinions, and that in no measured terms, nor in regard to
insignificant questions, although formerly you gave Origen marvellous praise. I suppose,
therefore, that you would not even yourself be contented to be in error with these men; al-
though the language which I refer to is equivalent to an assertion that in this matter they
have not erred. For who is there that would consent to be knowingly mistaken, with whatever
company he might share his errors? Three of the seven therefore alone remain, Eusebius of
Emesa, Theodorus of Heraclea, and John, whom you afterwards mention, who formerly
presided as pontiff over the Church of Constantinople.
24. However, if you inquire or recall to memory the opinion of our Ambrose,2056 and
also of our Cyprian,2057 on the point in question, you will perhaps find that I also have not
been without some whose footsteps I follow in that which I have maintained. At the same
time, as I have said already, it is to the canonical Scriptures alone that I am bound to yield
such implicit subjection as to follow their teaching, without admitting the slightest suspicion
that in them any mistake or any statement intended to mislead could find a place. Wherefore,
when I look round for a third name that I may oppose three on my side to your three, I
might indeed easily find one, I believe, if my reading had been extensive; but one occurs to
2054 Jerome’s Letter, LXXV. sec. 6, p.335.
2055 Ibid. sec. 4, p. 334.
2056 In his Commentary on Galations.
2057 In his letter, LXX., to Quintus; Ante-Nicene Fathers, Am. ed. vol. v. p. 377.
799
To Jerome