SECTION 4
James 2:1-13
RESPECT OF PERSONS
James 2:1-4
1 My brethren,-With this warm and friendly phrase, characteristic of James, a new theme begins. This brotherly address was the manner in which the writer often began a fresh topic. (James 1:19; James 2:5-6; James 3:1; James 5:7.) Inasmuch as it was his intention to rebuke the brethren to whom he wrote for serious and repeated infractions of the law of love, it was fitting that this subdivision should thus begin. For the significance of the word "brethren," the implications involved in its use, and the lessons applicable to us today therein, see the comments on James 1:2.
hold not the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory, with respect of persons.---"The faith of our Lord Jesus Christ," (ten pistin tou kuriou hemon Iesou Christou) is not, of course, the faith which Christ exercises; it is the whole of the Christian religion, represented under the phrase, "the faith," where a vital part thereof it made to stand for, and represent, the whole of it. James is saying here, "My brethren, do not hold to Christianity and at the same time show partiality and special concern for those who are rich or highly favored of the world." It is, in effect, to say: Don't try to be a Christian and a hypocrite at the same time! The disposition which prompts one disciple of the Lord to entertain and exhibit favoritism for another, on external grounds, and because of worldly considerations, is wholly foreign to the spirit of Christianity, and a violent perversion of genuine religion. Christ is identified in the passage as "the Lord of glory," not without much significance in the connection in which it appears. Its meaning is much the same as "the glorious Lord," and was doubtless introduced to show that in spite of, and despite the poverty and extreme humiliation to which he was subjected while on earth, his is now a position of great glory, a glory which he offers to his humble disciples, and grounded in Christian character, not on fame or worldly possessions.
This "faith" Christians are not to hold "with respect of persons." "Hold not," is me echete, present active imperative of echo, with the negative; i.e., quit having the habit of holding the faith in such fashion. It will be observed that here, and often elsewhere in the Epistle, the writer repeatedly returns to his theme that it is impossible for one properly to approach God in worship if the heart is not right, or if the conduct is corrupt. Though James is filled with injunctions the design of which was to impress his readers with the necessity of practical religion, ever emphasized is the fact that such will result in a blessing only when purity of heart and life characterize the worshipper.
"With respect of persons," is from en prosopolepsiais, compounded from the nouns prosopon (which means face, countenance), and lempsia, derived from lambano, to receive, thus, literally, to receive face! As used here, it signifies to show regard for the external circumstances of another, and to exhibit favoritism on the ground of rank, wealth, social position, worldly attainment and fame. It is this disposition which James condemns, and which our Lord so sharply rebuked while on earth. (Luke 20:21.) Partiality, based on worldly or material considerations, is so far removed from the true spirit of Christ, that for any of the disciples to exhibit such is a violent perversion of the Christian religion. For other instances of the word, see Romans 2:11; Ephesians 6:9; Colossians 3:25. God does not show respect of persons, and neither may we. It was this which impressed Peter in the incident of the great sheet: "Of a truth I perceive that God is no respecter of persons: but in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is acceptable to him." (Acts 10:34.)
Having seen that all are equal before God, and that it is sinful to show respect of persons from worldly considerations, inasmuch as every disciple is entitled to the same privileges in Christ (Galatians 3:26-29), it is an extension of this beyond proper bounds to imply that there are no differences obtaining between men. We are taught, in the New Testament to "honor the king" (1 Peter 2:13), and to pray for those in high places (1 Timothy 2:2).
Elders, deacons, aged men and women, dignitaries, men of great faith and courage, are often singled out, in the Scriptures, and declared to be worthy of special regard for their works of faith, their labors of love, and patience in hope they exhibit. (1 Timothy 5:17; 1 Timothy 3:13; 1 Timothy 5:1-3; Hebrews 11 :lff; 2 Peter 2:10-11.) What is taught is that there is no place for worldly acclaim in Christianity, and that all such reverence in public worship is unseemly and sinful. Inasmuch as God is no respecter of persons, neither should we be.
2 For if there come into your synagogue---"Synagogue," (sunaagogen), from sun, with, and ago, to gather, thus, literally, to assemble with, meant, in the apostolic age, (a) a congregation assembled; (b) the place where the assembly took place. It seems quite obvious, from the context, that it is the first of these meetings-a congregation assembled-which is intended here. If to us today it appears strange that a Christian writer, addressing Christians regarding conduct in a Christian assembly should, nevertheless, refer to the event under a Jewish appellation, let it be remembered that the religious background of the writer and the people to whom he wrote was wholly Jewish; that these impressions lingered for a long time; that the Jewish influence was strongly felt and exhibited throughout the apostolic age; and that terms were of necessity used which would convey as fully as possible to Jewish people the mind and message of the Spirit through James.
a man with a gold ring, in fine clothing,---Occasionally a man of means would visit the assemblies of the saints and, as has ever been characteristic of many people, the disposition to fawn upon such, and to show them special honors, was a temptation to which men in every age have been subjected, and to which they sometimes yielded. The phrase, "a man with a gold ring," is, in the Greek Testament, aner chrusodaktuli-0s, literally, a gold ringed man! This indicates that such a one would be possessed of many rings, and would wear them in ostentatious fashion. An ancient writer mentions one man who wore six rings on each finger, day and night, and did not remove them when he bathed. The historians record that Hannibal, after a great battle in which his forces were successful, sent three bushels of gold rings from the fingers of Roman knights killed in the conflict as a trophy to Carthage. Moreover, the man in the mind of the writer, in addition to the grand display of rings which he wore, was arrayed "in fine clothing," (en estheti lampria, brilliant, gaily colored garments), which attracted much attention from those less endowed.
and there come in also a poor man in vile clothing ;---This poor man, in the illustration, was much worse off than we ordinarily mean by the adjective poor today. The word is ptochos, a beggar (Matthew 19:21), one dependent on the charity of others for his very livelihood, not simply one with but little of this world's goods, yet with a sufficiency for living. His apparel, in sharp contrast with that of the richly bedecked man described above is described as "vile clothing," (en rnparai estheta, squalid, cheap, perhaps dirty). Though their economic status is as different as day and night, and though, in social rank, they are as far apart as the poles, they are both in church, and there stand equal before God who respects not the persons of men.
3 and ye have regard to him that weareth the fine clothing,---How characteristic of men so to do, and what common human weakness is here evidenced! "Ye have regard for," is epiblepsete de epi, aorist active subjunctive of epibelpo, to gaze with favor upon, and thus to be impressed, as in this instance, with the dazzling gold ornaments, and the brilliant display of clothing worn by the affluent man.
and say, Sit thou here in a good placc;---(Su kathou hode kalos), "You (emphatic) sit here in a good place"; i.e., a place of honor and prestige. The most coveted place in a synagogue, to a Jew, was near the end of the building, facing Jerusalem, and where the ark in which the sacred roll of the law was kept. In the illustration which James uses, of course based upon actual observance, the visitor is escorted to the most favored place in the building and with great deference there seated.
and ye say to the poor man, stand thou there, or sit under my footstool;---There is thinly veiled contempt in the words of the usher to the poor man, and no regard whatsoever shown for his comfort. He is not invited to sit in the usual places at all; he is rudely told to stand ; he is not escorted to any place ; but coldly instructed to find his own; with a contemptuous wave of the hand, the usher says, in effect, "Stand there, or sit, if you must, under my footstool, the place where I rest my feet." For a visitor to be required to stand, while the regular attendants sat was extreme discourtesy; and it was little better to be permitted, grudgingly, to sit under the stall where the people usually placed their feet. It was James' intention to show, in this striking contrast, the difference people are disposed to make between the rich and the poor, and to condemn such. In view of this, what must our Lord think of that attitude of mind and heart which often prompts people, themselves alleged suppliants before the throne of grace and in need of much mercy, to array themselves in the most ostentatious garments possible, and to parade down the aisles of New Testament church buildings preening like peacocks to the admiration of some and the envy of others?
4 do ye not make distinctions among yourselves,---The phrases "do ye not make distinctions," and "among yourselves," both have marginal readings, in the American Standard Version of the Scriptures, thus indicating a difference in view among the translators as to the preferred rendering. For, "do you not make distinctions," there is the footnote, "are ye not divided," and for "among yourselves," the footnote reads, "in your own mind." Where the footnotes placed in the text, the passage would read, "Are ye not divided in your own mind .. .. " The verb, "make distinctions," is, in the Greek text, diekrithete, first aorist passive indicative of diakrino, to separate; and, the construction of the sentence is such that an affirmative answer was expected from the question raised. The verb is translated "doubteth," in James I:6, and in similar fashion in Acts 10:20, and Romans 14:23.
There is, therefore, two possible interpretations, depending on whether the translation in the text, or in the footnotes, is followed. If the first, the meaning is, "Do you not recognize differences among you based upon material considerations? Is it not true that you fawn upon the rich, when they enter your assemblies, and do you not treat with contempt the poor?" If the second, the meaning is, "When you show partiality, on the basis of economic standing or other material and worldly considerations, were you not exhibiting doubt (disbelief) in the teaching of our Lord who straitly forbade all such in his teaching?" In view of the fact that the word translated "distinctions" is used uniformly to express doubt, in the New Testament, it would appear that the second of these interpretations is the more probable one. The phrase which follows, "and become judges of evil thoughts," supports this view. The conduct of those to whom James wrote (the verb indicates that they were practicing the things which he condemned here) was such that they were wavering between what the Lord taught regarding fame, riches, social standing, and the like, and the temptation to show special favors to those well circumstanced. To use one of James' phrases, they were men of two minds; i.e., "double-minded." (James 1:8.)
and become judges with evil thoughts?---These people had, by their exhibition of favoritism toward the rich, resulting from the wavering of their faith, become "judges with evil thoughts." The word "judges," is from dialogismon, from dialogismos, reasoning. The word is a legal term ; and, as here used, describes the litigation which resulted from the conflicting views which they felt, producing the doubt earlier mentioned. The conflict which existed in their minds, between what they knew the Lord taught regarding the rich and riches, and their desire to show preferential regard for such made them a court of conflict! These conflicts were as pronounced as would be the opposing views of lawyers arguing a case in court.
From this section we learn that it was evidently quite unusual for a rich man to visit an assembly of the saints. The appearance of such a man was so exceptional that when it occurred considerable excitement prevailed, prompting the brethren to exercise themselves unduly in assigning to him the most honorable seat possible. Such a disposition was highly displeasing to God with whom there is no respect of persons. In his sight, all men are equal in privilege and promise; and with him, one soul is a precious as another. It is evil to show honor to any man simply because he wears better clothing, lives in a more pretentious house, or has a bigger bank account. What prompts people to show special regard for the rich?
Usually the motive is a selfish one. There is lurking in the back of the mind the idea that some day it may be necessary to ask favors of the rich, and it is therefore expedient to flatter them. Why bother with the poor? They can never do anything for us, anyway. Ah, how many sins stem from simple selfishness !