But the historical question is one of some interest, and
I shall very briefly consider it. We have indeed the
“Acta” of this council, but I cannot but agree with the
very learned Jesuit Petavius and the Gallican Tillemont in thinking
them in a very unsatisfactory condition. I am fully aware of the
temerity of making such a suggestion, but I cannot help feeling that in
the remarks of the Roman representatives, especially in those of the
presbyter-legate, there is some anachronism. Be this as it may,
it is a fact that the Acts do not recite that this letter of
Cyril’s was read, nor do they state that the Anathemas were
received. I would suggest, however, that for those who defend
John of Antioch, and criticise the action of St. Cyril, it is the
height of inconsistency to deny that the Council adopted the
Anathemas. If it was the bitterly partisan assembly that they
would have us believe, absolutely under the control of Cyril, there is
nothing that, ὰ
priori, they would have been more sure to do than adopt the
Anathemas which were universally looked upon as the very fulcrum on
which the whole matter turned.