other way than by such a motion as is supposed. That body therefore must be reputed to
move, that can be supposed so to do, according to the Laws of Nature universally observed
in other things. It is upon them that God impresses that Centrifugal Force.
n.b. This answers the objection that might be raised from what Newton says of Absolute,
and Relative, Motion, and that distinguishing property of absolute Circular Motion, that
there was a Centrifugal Force in the body moved; for God causes a Centrifugal Force in that
body, that can be supposed to move circularly, consistently with the Laws of Motion, in that
and in all other things, on which it has a near, or a remote, dependence, and which must be
supposed to move in order to the observance of those Laws in the Universe. For instance,
when a bushel, with water in it, is violently whirled round, before the water takes the impres-
sion, there is a continual change of position between the water and the parts of the bushel;
but yet that must not be supposed to move as fast as that position is altered; because if we
follow it, it will not hold out consistent with the Laws of motion in the Universe, for if the
Water moves, then the bushel does not move; and if the Bushel does not move, then the
Earth moves round the bushel, every time that seems to turn round; but there can be no
such alteration in the motion of the Earth created naturally, or in observance of the Laws
of Nature.
[2.] Place of minds. Our common way of conceiving of what is Spiritual, is very gross,
and shadowy, and corporeal, with dimensions and figure, &c. though it be supposed to be
very clear, so that we can see through it. If we would get a right notion of what is Spiritual,
we must think of Thought, or Inclination, or Delight. How large is that thing in the Mind
which they call Thought? Is Love square, or round? Is the surface of Hatred rough, or
smooth? Is Joy an inch, or a foot, in diameter? These are Spiritual things, and why should
we then form such a ridiculous idea of Spirits, as to think them so long, so thick, or so wide;
or to think there is a necessity of their being square, or round, or some other certain figure?
Therefore Spirits cannot be in place, in such a sense, that all, within the given limits,
shall be where the Spirit is, and all without such a circumscription, where he is not; but in
this sense only, that all created Spirits have clearer and more strongly impressed ideas of
things, in one place than in another, or can produce effects here, and not there; and as this
place alters, so Spirits move. In Spirits united to bodies, the Spirit more strongly perceives
things where the body is, and can there immediately produce effects; and in this sense the
soul can be said to be in the same place where the body is. And this law is, that we call the
Union between soul and body. So the soul may be said to be in the brain; because ideas, that
come by the body, immediately ensue, only on alterations that are made there; and the soul
most immediately produces effects no where else.
No doubt that all Finite Spirits, united to bodies or not, are thus in place; that is, that
they perceive, or passively receive, ideas, only of created things, that are in some particular
place at a given time. At least a Finite Spirit cannot thus be in all places at a time, equally.
478
NO.IV. Remarks in Mental Philosophy. The Mind.