the heart; and, consequently, according to common sense, have no sincere goodness in
them, having no Virtue of heart in them. To have a virtuous heart, is to have a heart that
favours Virtue, and is friendly to it, and not one perfectly cold and indifferent about it.
And besides, the actions that are done in a state of Indifference, or that arise immediately
out of such a state, cannot be virtuous, because, by the supposition, they are not determined
by any preceding choice. For if there be preceding choice, then choice intervenes between
the act and the state of Indifference; which is contrary to the supposition of the act arising
immediately out of Indifference. But those acts which are not determined by preceding
choice, cannot be virtuous or vicious, by Arminian principles, because they are not determ-
ined by the Will. So that neither one way, nor the other, can any actions be virtuous or vicious,
according to those principles. If the action be determined by a preceding act of choice, it
cannot be virtuous; because the action is not done in a state of Indifference, nor does imme-
diately arise from such a state; and so is not done in a state of Liberty, If the action be not
determined by a preceding act of choice, then it cannot be virtuous; because then the Will
is not self-determined in it. So that it is made certain, that neither Virtue nor Vice can ever
find any place in the universe!
Moreover, that it is necessary to a virtuous action that it be performed in a state of In-
difference, under a notion of that being a state of liberty, is contrary to common sense; as
it is a dictate of common sense, that Indifference itself, in many cases, is vicious, and so to
a high degree. As if when I see my neighbour or near friend, and one who has in the highest
degree merited of me, in extreme distress, and ready to perish, I find an Indifference in my
heart with respect to any thing proposed to be done, which I can easily do, for his relief. So
if it should be proposed to me to blaspheme God, or kill my father, or do numberless other
things, which might be mentioned; the being indifferent, for a moment, would be highly
vicious and vile.
And it may be further observed, that to suppose this Liberty of Indifference is essential
to Virtue and Vice, destroys the great difference of degrees of the guilt of different crimes,
and takes away the heinousness of the most flagitious, horrid iniquities; such as adultery,
bestiality, murder, perjury, blasphemy, &c. For, according to these principles, there is no
harm at all in having the mind in a state of perfect Indifference with respect to these crimes;
nay, it is absolutely necessary in order to any Virtue in avoiding them, or Vice in doing
them. But for the mind to be in a state of Indifference with respect to them, is to be next
door to doing them: it is then infinitely near to choosing, and so committing the fact: for
equilibrium is the next step to a degree of preponderation; and one, even the least degree
of preponderation (all things considered) is choice. And not only so, but for the Will to be
in a state of perfect equilibrium with respect to such crimes, is for the mind to be in such a
state, as to be full as likely to choose them as to refuse them, to do them as to omit them.
And if our minds must be in such a state, wherein it is as near to choosing as refusing, and
660
SECTION VI. Liberty of Indifference, not only not necessary to Virtue,…