I confess that to my mind there is an antecedent
probability that the view which has here been followed is correct.
Judging by the general history of doctrine, one should not expect that
the formal ecclesiastical meaning of the word should have obtained
everywhere so early. Nothing is more certain than that the doctrines
themselves of the Holy Trinity and the Incarnation were developed, or,
to speak more definitely, that the propositions containing them were
acknowledged, from the earliest times; but the particular terms which
now belong to them are most uniformly of a later date. Ideas were
brought out, but technical phrases did not obtain. Not that these
phrases did not exist, but either not as technical, or in use in a
particular School or Church, or with a particular writer, or as
ἅπαξ
λεγόμενα, as words
discussed, nay resisted, perhaps used by some local Council, and then
at length accepted generally from their obvious propriety. Thus the
words of the Schools pass into the service of the Catholic Church.
Instead then of the word ὑπόστασις being, as
Maran says, received in the East “summo consensu,” from the
date of Noetus or at least Sabellius, or of Bull’s opinion
“apud Catholicos Dionysii ætate ratum et fixum
illud fuisse, tres esse in divinis hypostases,” I would consider
that the present use of the word was in the first instance Alexandrian,
and that it was little more than Alexandrian till the middle of the
fourth century.