surely most of them at the same time were without Mr. W.’s moral sincerity; for it is
abundantly manifest, that the body of the people fell away to idolatry in Egypt. (See Levit.
xvii. 7. Josh. xxiv. 14. Ezek. xx. 8. and Ezek. xxiii. 3, 8, 27.) And there is not the least appear-
ance of any more exception, either in the precepts or history of the Old Testament, of the
case of moral insincerity, in such as attended these ordinances, than of ungodliness, or an
unsanctified state.
Mr. S. urges, that Jesus Christ himself partook of the passover with Judas; and thence he
would argue, that it was lawful for an unregenerate person to partake of the Lord’s supper.
But there can be no argument, in any sort, drawn from this, to prove that it is lawful for
men to partake of the Lord’s supper without sanctifying grace, any more than that it is lawful
for them to partake without moral sincerity: for it is every whit as evident, that Judas was at
that time without moral sincerity, as that he was unregenerate. We have no greater evidence,
in all the scripture history, of the moral insincerity of any one man, than of Judas, at the
time when he partook of the passover with Christ; he having just then bargained with the
high priest to betray him, and being then in prosecution of the horrid design of the murder
of the Son of God.
If any thing contrary to my principles could be argued from all Israel being required,
throughout their generations, to come to the passover and circumcision, it would be this;
that all persons, of all sorts, throughout all christendom, might lawfully come to baptism
and the Lord’s Supper; godly and ungodly, the knowing and the ignorant, the moral and the
vicious, orthodox and heretical, protestants and papists alike. But this does not agree with
Mr. W.’s principles, any better than with mine.
2009
SECTION XII. The passover and circumcision.