But to what has been already
said, ought to be added some notice of that position which they make a
kind of foundation of their impiety in their discussions concerning the
Incarnation, the position, namely, that not the whole man has been
saved by Him, but only the half of man, I mean the body. Their object
in such a malignant perversion of the true doctrine, is to show that
the less exalted statements, which our Lord utters in His humanity, are
to be thought to have issued from the Godhead Itself, that so they may
show their blasphemy to have a stronger case, if it is upheld by the
actual acknowledgment of the Lord. For this reason it is that Eunomius
says, “He who in the last days became man did not take upon
Himself the man made up of soul and body.” But, after searching
through all the inspired and sacred Scripture, I do not find any such
statement as this, that the Creator of all things, at the time of His
ministration here on earth for man, took upon Himself flesh only
without a soul. Under stress of necessity, then, looking to the object
contemplated by the plan of salvation, to the doctrines of the Fathers,
and to the inspired Scriptures, I will endeavour to confute the impious
falsehood which is being fabricated with regard to this matter. The
Lord came “to seek and to save that which was lost Cf.
S. Luke xix. 10.” Now it was not the body merely, but
the whole man, compacted of soul and body, that was lost: indeed, if we
are to speak more exactly, the soul was lost sooner than the body. For
disobedience is a sin, not of the body, but of the will: and the will
properly belongs to the soul, from which the whole disaster of our
nature had its beginning, as the threat of God, that admits of no
falsehood, testifies in the declaration that, in the day that they
should eat of the forbidden fruit, death without respite would attach
to the act. Now since the condemnation of man was twofold, death
correspondingly effects in each part of our nature the deprivation of
the twofold life that operates in him who is thus mortally stricken.
For the death of the body consists in the extinction of the means of
sensible perception, and in the dissolution of the body into its
kindred elements: but “the soul that sinneth,” he saith,
“it shall die Ezek. xviii.
20..” Now sin is
nothing else than alienation from God, Who is the true and only life.
Accordingly the first man lived many hundred years after his
disobedience, and yet God lied not when He said, “In the day that
ye eat thereof ye shall surely die Cf. Gen. ii. 17.” For by
the fact of his alienation from the true life, the sentence of death
was ratified against him that self-same day: and after this, at a much
later time, there followed also the bodily death of Adam. He therefore
Who came for this cause that He might seek and save that which was
lost, (that which the shepherd in the parable calls the sheep,) both
finds that which is lost, and carries home on His shoulders the whole
sheep, not its skin only, that He may make the man of God complete,
united to the deity in body and in soul. And thus He Who was in all
points tempted like as we are, yet without sin, left no part of our
nature which He did not take upon Himself. Now the soul is not sin
though it is capable of admitting sin into it as the result of being
ill-advised: and this He sanctifies by union with Himself for this end,
that so the lump may be holy along with the first-fruits. Wherefore
also the Angel, when informing Joseph of the destruction of the enemies
of the Lord, said, “They are dead which sought the young
Child’s life S. Matt. ii. 20. The word ψυχήν may be
rendered by either “life” or “soul.”,” (or
“soul”): and the Lord says to the Jews, “Ye seek to
kill Me, a man that hath told you the truth S. John viii. 40. This is the only
passage in which our Lord speaks of Himself by this term..” Now by “Man” is not meant
the body of a man only, but that which is composed of both, soul and
body. And again, He says to them, “Are ye angry at Me, because I
have made a man every whit whole on the Sabbath day S. John vii. 20?” And what He meant by “every
whit whole,” He showed in the other Gospels, when He said to the
man who was let down on a couch in the midst, “Thy sins be
forgiven thee,” which is a healing of the soul, and, “Arise
and walk Cf.
S. Luke v. 20, 23, and the parallel
passages in S. Matt.
ix. and S. Mark ii.,” which has regard to the body:
and in the Gospel of S. John, by liberating the soul also from its own
malady after He had given health to the body, where He saith,
“Thou art made whole, sin no more S. John v. 14,” thou, that is, who hast been cured in
both, I mean in soul and in body. For so too does S. Paul speak,
“for to make in Himself of twain one new man Eph. ii. 15..” And so too He foretells that at the
time of His Passion He would voluntarily detach His soul from His body,
saying, “No man taketh” my soul “from Me, but I lay
it down of Myself: I have power to lay it down, and I have power to
take it again Cf.
S. John x. 17, 18. Here again the
word ψυχήν is
rendered in the A.V. by “life.”.” Yea, the prophet David also,
according to the interpretation of the great Peter, said with foresight
of Him, “Thou wilt not leave My soul in hell, neither wilt Thou
suffer Thine Holy One to see corruption Ps. xvi. 8. Acts ii. 27,
31.,” while the Apostle Peter thus expounds
the saying, that “His soul was not left in hell, neither His
flesh did see corruption.” For His Godhead, alike before taking
flesh and in the flesh and after His Passion, is immutably the same,
being at all times what It was by nature, and so continuing for ever.
But in the suffering of His human nature the Godhead fulfilled the
dispensation for our benefit by severing the soul for a season from the
body, yet without being Itself separated from either of those elements
to which it was once for all united, and by joining again the elements
which had been thus parted, so as to give to all human nature a
beginning and an example which it should follow of the resurrection
from the dead, that all the corruptible may put on incorruption, and
all the mortal may put on immortality, our first-fruits having been
transformed to the Divine nature by its union with God, as Peter said,
“This same Jesus Whom ye crucified, hath God made both Lord and
Christ Acts ii. 36. A further
exposition of Gregory’s views on this passage will be found in
Book V.;” and we might cite many passages of
Scripture to support such a position, showing how the Lord, reconciling
the world to Himself by the Humanity of Christ, apportioned His work of
benevolence to men between His soul and His body, willing through His
soul and touching them through His body. But it would be superfluous to
encumber our argument by entering into every detail.