personal identity, and so the derivation of the pollution and guilt of past sins in the same
person, depends on an arbitrary divine constitution; and this, even though we should allow
the same consciousness not to be the only thing which constitutes oneness of person, but
should, besides that, suppose sameness of substance requisite. For, if same consciousness
be one thing necessary to personal identity, and this depends on God’s sovereign constitution,
it will still follow that personal identity depends on God’s sovereign constitution.
And with respect to the identity of created substance itself, in the different moments of
its duration, I think we shall greatly mistake, if we imagine it to be like that absolute, inde-
pendent identity of the first being, whereby he is the same yesterday, to-day, and for ever.
Nay, on the contrary, it may be demonstrated, that even this oneness of created substance,
existing at different times, is a merely dependent identity; dependent on the pleasure and
sovereign constitution of him who worketh all in all. This will follow from what is generally
allowed, and is certainly true, that God not only created all things, and gave them being at
first, but continually preserves them, and upholds them in being. This being a matter of
considerable importance, it may be worthy here to be considered with a little attention. Let
us inquire therefore, in the first place, whether it be not evident, that God does continually,
by his immediate power, uphold every created substance in being; and then let us see the
consequence.
That God does, by his immediate power, uphold every created substance in being, will
be manifest, if we consider that their present existence is a dependent existence, and therefore
is an effect and must have some cause; and the cause must be one of these two; either the
antecedent existence of the same substance, or else the power of the Creator. But it cannot
be the antecedent existence of the same substance. For instance, the existence of the body of
the moon, at this present moment, cannot be the effect of its existence at the last foregoing
moment. For not only was what existed the last moment, no active cause, but wholly a
passive thing; but this also is to be considered, that no cause can produce effects in a time
and place in which itself is not. It is plain, nothing can exert itself, or operate, when and
where it is not existing. But the moon’s past existence was neither where nor when its present
existence is. In point of time, what is past entirely ceases, when present existence begins;
otherwise it would not be past. The past moment has ceased, and is gone, when the present
moment takes place; and no more coexists with it, than any other moment that had ceased,
twenty years ago. Nor could the past existence of the particles of this moving body produce
effects in any other place, than where it then was. But its existence at the present moment,
in every point of it, is in a different place, from where its existence was at the last preceding
moment. From these things, I suppose, it will certainly follow, that the present existence,
either of this, or any other created substance, cannot be an effect of its past existence. The
existences (so to speak) of an effect, or thing dependent, in different parts of space or dura-
tion, though ever so near one to another, do not at all co-exist one with the other; and
1156
CHAPTER III. The Imputation of Adam's Sin stated.