Chapter II.—St.
Luke’s Gospel, Selected by Marcion as His Authority, and
Mutilated by Him. The Other Gospels Equally Authoritative.
Marcion’s Terms of Discussion, However, Accepted, and Grappled
with on the Footing of St. Luke’s Gospel Alone.
You have now our answer to the
Antitheses
compendiously indicated by us.
3516
I pass on to give a
proof of the Gospel
3517
—not, to be
sure, of Jewry, but of Pontus—having become meanwhile
3518
adulterated; and this shall
indicate
3519
the order by which
we proceed. We lay it down as our first position, that the evangelical
Testament
3520
has apostles for
its authors,
3521
to whom was
assigned by the Lord Himself this office of publishing the gospel.
Since, however, there are apostolic
3522
men
also,
3523
they are yet not alone, but appear with
apostles and after apostles; because the preaching of disciples might
be open to the suspicion of an affectation of glory, if there did not
accompany it
3524
the authority of
the masters, which means that of Christ,
3525
for it was that which made the apostles their masters. Of the apostles,
therefore, John and Matthew first instil
3526
faith into us; whilst of apostolic men, Luke and Mark renew it
afterwards.
3527
These all start
with the same principles of the faith,
3528
so
far as relates to the one only God the Creator and His Christ, how that
He was born of the Virgin, and came to fulfil
3529
the law and the prophets. Never mind
3530
if there does
occur some variation in the order of their narratives, provided that
there be agreement in the essential matter
3531
of
the faith, in which there is disagreement with Marcion. Marcion, on the
other hand, you must know,
3532
ascribes no author
to his Gospel, as if it could not be allowed him to affix a title to
that from which it was no crime (in his eyes) to subvert
3533
the very body. And here I might now make a
stand, and contend that a work ought not to be recognised, which holds
not its head erect, which exhibits no consistency, which gives no
promise of credibility from the fulness of its title and the just
profession of its author. But we prefer to join issue
3534
on every point; nor shall we leave
unnoticed
3535
what may fairly be
understood to be on our side.
3536
Now, of the authors
whom we possess, Marcion seems to have singled out Luke
3537
for his mutilating process.
3538
Luke, however, was not an apostle, but only
an apostolic man; not a master, but a disciple, and so inferior to a
master—at least as far subsequent to
3539
him as the apostle whom he followed (and that, no doubt, was
Paul
3540
) was subsequent to the others; so that, had
Marcion even published his Gospel in the name of St. Paul himself, the
single authority of the document,
3541
destitute of
all support from preceding authorities, would not be a sufficient basis
for our faith. There would be still wanted that Gospel which St. Paul
found in existence, to which he yielded
his belief, and with which he so
earnestly wished his own to agree, that he actually on that account
went up to Jerusalem to know and consult the apostles, “lest he
should run, or had been running in vain;”
3542
in
other words, that the faith which he had learned, and the gospel which
he was preaching, might be in accordance with theirs. Then, at last,
having conferred with the (primitive) authors, and having agreed with
them touching the rule of faith, they joined their hands in fellowship,
and divided their labours thenceforth in the office of preaching the
gospel, so that they were to go to the Jews, and St. Paul to the Jews
and the Gentiles. Inasmuch, therefore, as the enlightener of St.
Luke himself desired the authority of his predecessors for both his own
faith and preaching, how much more may not I require for Luke’s
Gospel that which was necessary for the Gospel of his master.
3543
3516
Expeditam a nobis.
3517
[The term
εὐαγγέλιον
was often employed for a written book, says Kaye (p. 298), who
refers to Book i. cap. 1.
supra, etc
.]
3518
Interim, perhaps
“occasionally.”
3519
Præstructuram.
3520
Instrumentum.
[See cap. 1,
supra
. And, above, note 9. Also in cap. iii. and
the Apology, (cap. xlvii.) he calls the Testaments,
Digests
,
or
Sancta Digesta
.]
3521
By this canon of his,
that the true Gospels must have for their authors either apostles or
companions and disciples of apostles, he shuts out the false Gospels of
the heretics, such as the Ebionites, Encratites, Nazarenes, and
Marcionites (Le Prieur).
3522
Apostolicos,
companions of the apostles associated in the authorship.
3523
He means, of course,
St. Mark and St. Luke.
3524
Adsistat illi.
3525
Immo Christi.
3526
Insinuant.
3527
Instaurant.
3528
Isdem regulis.
3529
Supplementum.
3530
Viderit.
3531
De capite.
3532
Scilicet.
3533
Evertere.
3534
Congredi.
3535
Dissimulamus.
3536
Ex nostro.
3537
Compare
Irenæus,
Adversus Hæreses
(Harvey), i. 25 and iii. 11;
also Epiphanius,
Hær
. xlii. See also the editor’s
notes on the passages in Irenæus, who quotes other authorities
also, and shows the particulars of Marcion’s mutilations.
[Vol. I. 429.]
3538
Quem cæderet.
3539
Posterior.
3540
See Hieronymi,
Catal. Scriptt. Eccles
. 7, and Fabricius’
notes.
3541
Instrumenti.
3542
Gal. ii. 2
.
3543
[Dr. Holmes not
uniformly, yet constantly inserts the prefix St. before the name of
Paul, and brackets it, greatly disfiguring the page. It is not in
our author’s text, but I venture to dispense with the
ever-recurring brackets.]