Eusebius states, just below, that Pius held office fifteen years,
and in his Chronicle he gives the same figure. In that work
(Armen. version) he places his accession in the first year of Antoninus
Pius, though the version of Jerome assigns it to the fifth year, and
with this Eusebius agrees in his History, for in the previous
chapter he puts the accession of Hyginus in the first year of Antoninus
Pius, and here tells us that Hyginus held office four years. Lipsius
assigns Pius’ episcopate to the years 139–154, as the
earliest possible termini; the years 141–156 as the latest. But
since we learn from chapter 14, below, that Polycarp was in Rome during
the episcopate of Anicetus, and from other sources (see chapter 15,
note 2) that he was martyred in Asia Minor in 155 or 156, we may assume
it as certain that Pius cannot have held office as late as 156. The
earlier date for his death (154) may therefore be accepted as more
probable. The Liberian and Felician Catalogues put Anicetus between
Hyginus and Pius; but that is certainly incorrect, for, in support of
the order given here by Eusebius, we have the testimony both of
Hegesippus, quoted below, in chap. 22, and of Irenæus (III. 3).
Pius is commonly regarded as the first monarchical bishop in the strict
sense, the so-called bishops before his time having been simply leading
presbyters or presbyter bishops of the Roman church (see chap. 11, note
14). According to the Muratorian Fragment and the Liberian Catalogue,
Pius was the brother of Hermas, the author of the Shepherd. Upon
this alleged relationship, see Bk. III. chap. 3, note 23.