4. But we do not purpose delaying further on this part of the subject, lest we seem de-
sirous to stir up most violent strife, and engage in agitating contests.
Let there be, as you affirm, that crowd of deities, let there be numberless families of
gods; we assent, agree, and do not examine too closely, nor in any part of the subject do we
assail the doubtful and uncertain positions you hold. This, however, we demand, and ask
you to tell us, whence you have discovered, or how you have learned, whether there are
these gods,3927 whom you believe to be in heaven and serve, or some others unknown by
reputation and name? For it may be that beings exist whom you do not believe to do so;
and that those of whose existence you feel assured, are found nowhere in the universe. For
465
you have at no time been borne aloft to the stars of heaven, at no time have seen the face
and countenance of each; and then established here the worship of the same gods, whom
you remembered to be there, as having been known and seen by you. But this, too, we again
would learn from you, whether they have received these names by which you call them, or
assumed them themselves on the days of purification.3928 If these are divine and celestial
names, who reported them to you? But if, on the other hand, these names have been applied
to them by you, how could you give names to those whom you never saw, and whose char-
acter or circumstances you in no wise3929 knew?
3927 According to Orelli’s punctuation, “whether there are these gods in heaven whom,” etc.
3928 So LB. and later edd., from a conj. of Meursius, reading diebus lustricis for the ms. ludibriis; read by
some, and understood by others, as ludicris, i.e., festal days.
3929 The ms. followed by Hild. and Oehler, reads neque…in ulla cognatione—“in no relationship,” for which
the other edd. give cognitione, as above.
Chapter IV.
1091
Chapter IV.