CHAP. IX.] NOT THE FATHER ONLY WHO HAS IMMORTALITY. 57
Son to be visible, not by having taken flesli of the Virgin,
but aforetime also in Himself For He Himself, they say,
appeared to the eyes of the fathers. And if you say to them,
In whatever manner, then, the Son is visible in Himself, in
that manner also He is mortal in Himself; so that it plainly
follows that you would have this saying also understood only
of the Father, viz. " Who only hath immortality
;
" for if the Son
is mortal from having taken upon Him our flesh, then allow that
it is on account of this flesh that He is also visible : they reply,
that it is not on account of this flesh that they say that the Son
is mortal ; but that, just as He was also before visible, so He
was also before mortal. For if they say the Son is mortal from
having taken our flesh, then it is not the Father alone without
the Son who hath immortality ; because His Word also has
immortality, by which all things were made. For He did not
therefore lose His immortality, because He took mortal flesh ;
seeing that it could not happen even to the human soul, that
it should die with the body, when the Lord Himself says,
" Fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill
the soul." ^ Or, forsooth, also the Holy Spirit took flesh :
concerning wdiom certainly they will, Avithout doubt, be troubled
to say—if the Son is mortal on account of taking our flesh
—
in what manner they understand that the Father only has
immortality without the Son and the Holy Spirit, since, indeed,
the Holy Spirit did not take our flesh ; and if He has not
immortality, then the Son is not mortal on account of taking
our flesh ; but if the Holy Spirit has immortality, then it is
not said only of the Father, " AVho only hath immortality,"
And therefore they think they are able to prove that the Son
in Himself was mortal also before the incarnation, because
changeableness itself is not unfitly called mortality, according
to which the soul also is said to die ; not because it is changed
and turned into body, or into some substance other than itself,
but because, whatever in its own self-same substance is now
after another mode than it once was, is discovered to be mortal,
in so far as it has ceased to be what it was. Because then,
say thej^, before the Son of God was born of the Virgin
Mary, He Himself appeared to our fathers, not in one and the
1 Matt. X. 28.