questioned, had it not included Rome.…Nobody can maintain that the bishops of Antioch
and Alexandria were called patriarchs then, or that the jurisdiction they had then was co-
extensive with what they had afterward, when they were so called.…It is on this clause
[“since the like is customary for the Bishops of Rome also”] standing parenthetically between
what is decreed for the particular cases of Egypt and Antioch, and in consequence of the
interpretation given to it by Rufinus, more particularly, that so much strife has been raised.
Rufinus may rank low as a translator, yet, being a native of Aquileia, he cannot have been
ignorant of Roman ways, nor, on the other hand, had he greatly misrepresented them, would
his version have waited till the seventeenth century to be impeached.
Hefele.
The sense of the first words of the canon is as follows: “This ancient right is assigned
to the Bishop of Alexandria which places under his jurisdiction the whole diocese of Egypt.”
It is without any reason, then, that the French Protestant Salmasius (Saumaise), the
Anglican Beveridge, and the Gallican Launoy, try to show that the Council of Nice granted
to the Bishop of Alexandria only the rights of ordinary metropolitans.
Bishop Stillingfleet.
I do confess there was something peculiar in the case of the Bishop of Alexandria, for
all the provinces of Egypt were under his immediate care, which was Patriarchal as to extent,
but Metropolical in the administration.
16
Justellus.
This authority (ἐξουσία) is that of a Metropolitan which the Nicene Fathers decreed to
be his due over the three provinces named in this canon, Egypt, Libya, and Pentapolis, which
made up the whole diocese of Egypt, as well in matters civil as ecclesiastical.
On this important question Hefele refers to the dissertation of Dupin, in his work De
Antiqua Ecclesiæ Disciplina. Hefele says: “It seems to me beyond a doubt that in this canon
there is a question about that which was afterward called the patriarchate of the Bishop of
Alexandria; that is to say that he had a certain recognized ecclesiastical authority, not only
over several civil provinces, but also over several ecclesiastical provinces (which had their
own metropolitans);” and further on (p. 392) he adds: “It is incontestable that the civil
provinces of Egypt, Libya, Pentapolis and Thebaïs, which were all in subjection to the
Bishop of Alexandria, were also ecclesiastical provinces with their own metropolitans; and
consequently it is not the ordinary rights of metropolitans that the Sixth Canon of Nice
confers on the Bishop of Alexandria, but the rights of a superior Metropolitan, that is, of a
Patriarch.”
There only remains to see what were the bounds of the jurisdiction of the Bishop of
Antioch. The civil diocese of Oriens is shown by the Second Canon of Constantinople to
be conterminous with what was afterward called the Patriarchate of Antioch. The see of
Antioch had, as we know, several metropolitans subject to it, among them Cæsarea, under
63
Canon VI.