Elucidation.
————————————
(Stated in obscure terms, with advantage, p. 495.)
Turn
back to the
Second
Apology
of Justin (cap. ix.), “Eternal punishment not a mere
threat;”
4068
also to Clement
(
Stromata
, iv. cap. xxiv.), “the reason and end of divine
punishments.”
4069
Now compare
Gieseler
4070
(vol. i. p. 212)
for what he so sweepingly asserts. And on the doctrine of Origen,
let me quote a very learned and
on such points
a most capable
judge, the late erudite and pious
half-Gallican
Dr. Pusey.
He says:—
“Celsus and Origen are both witnesses that
Christians believed in the eternity of punishment. Celsus, to
weaken the force of the argument from the sufferings which the martyrs
underwent sooner than abjure Christianity, tells Origen that heathen
priests taught the same doctrine of eternal punishment as the
Christians, and that the only question was,
which was
right
.
4071
“Origen answers, ‘I should say that
the truth lies with those who are able to induce their hearers to
live as men convinced of the truth
of what they have
heard. Jews and Christians have been thus affected by the
doctrines which they hold about the world to come, the rewards of the
righteous, and the punishments of the wicked. Who have been moved
in this way, in regard to eternal punishments, by the teaching of
heathen priests and mystagogues?’
“Origen’s answer acknowledges that the
doctrine of eternal punishment had been taught to Christians, that One
[Christ] had taught it, and that it had produced the effects He had [in
view] in teaching it; viz., to set Christians to strive with all their
might to
conquer the sin
which produced it.”
4072
On this most painful subject my natural feelings
are much with Canon Farrar; but, after lifelong application to the
subject, I must think Dr. Pusey holds with his Master, Christ. I
feel willing to leave it all with Him who died for sinners, and the
cross shuts my mouth. “Herein is love;” and I cannot
dictate to such love, from my limited mind, and capacity, and knowledge
of His universe. Here let “
every thought
be brought
into captivity to the obedience of Christ.” Let us
sacrifice “imaginations and every high thing that exalteth
itself,” and leave our Master alike supreme in our affections and
over our intellectual powers. He merits such subjection.
Let us preach His words, and leave Him to explain them when He shall
“condemn every tongue that shall rise against Him in
judgment.”
Let me also refer to Bledsoe’s most solemn
and searching reply to John Foster; also to his answer to Lord
Kames’s effort to help the Lord out of a supposed
difficulty.
4073
I am sorry
that Tillotson exposed himself to a witty retort by the same author, in
these words: “If the Almighty really undertook to deceive
the world for its own good, it is a pity He did not take the precaution
to prevent the archbishop from
detecting the cheat
,…not
suffering his secret to get into the possession of one who has so
indiscreetly published it.” The awful importance of the
subject, and the recently awakened interest in its discussion, have led
me to enlarge this annotation.
4068
Our vol. i. p.
191.
4069
Our vol. ii. p.
437.
4070
Ed. Philadelphia,
1836.
4071
See this treatise,
Book VIII. cap. xlviii.,
infra
.
4072
What is of Faith as
to Everlasting Punishment
? in reply to Dr. Farrar’s
Challenge
, 1879. By the Rev. E. B. Pusey, D.D., Oxford,
1881.
4073
Theodicy
, pp.
295–311 (answer to Foster), p. 81 (to Lord Kames), p. 310 (to
Tillotson). I must confess that Bledsoe is
paulo iniquior
when he gives no reference to Tillotson’s language. If the
retort is based on the sermon (xxxv. vol. iii. p. 350, ed. folio, 1720)
on the “Eternity of Torment,” however, I do not think it
just. The latitudinarian primate restricts himself therein to a
very guarded statement of that reserved right by which any governor
commutes or remits punishment, though he cannot modify a promise of
reward. I wish modern apologists for the divine sovereignty had
not gone farther.