purifying faith; (p. 65. e. and p. 47. b. c.) Such as have the moral image of Christ appearing
in them, or supposed to be in them, and are to be loved on that account, (p. 68. c.) He allows,
that there ought to be some apprehension, some judgment of the mind, that they are
Christians and saints, and have the moral image of God in them. 387 (p. 68. c. d. e. p. 69. a.
and 71. d.) He allows, that they must be taken into the church under a notion of their being
godly, and with respect to such a character appearing on them: and very often insists, that
they themselves must make such a pretence. (p. 55. c. d. e. 388 p. 132. a. c. d. e. p. 136. d. p.
387 By this it appears, when Mr. W. speaks of the church’s rational judgment that persons have real holiness,
and the like, he does not mean merely treating them as such, in public administrations, and external conduct:
for here he speaks not of the external conduct, but of the apprehension of the understanding, and judgment of
the mind; and this as the foundation of the affection of the heart.
388 Mr. W—‘s words (p. 55. d. e) are pretty remarkable: “The reader (says he) will judge, whether the manner
of Mr. Edwards’s treating the question, and representing the opinion of Mr. Stoddard and others, in the words
I have quoted above, be not unaccountable; though this is neither the first nor the last time of his treating the
matter in such a manner: as if Mr. Stoddard and his adherents supposed persons were to be admitted without
any notion of their being godly, or any respect to such a character appearing on them, and that they themselves
are without such a pretence.” — Whereas, Mr. Stoddard expressly maintains, that men may be duly qualified,
and fit matter for church-membership, without saving grace. (Appeal, p. 15, 16.) And that they may and ought
to come, though they know themselves to be in a natural condition. (Doct. of Instituted Churches. p. 21. See
also his Sermon on the subject, p. 13.) And according to Mr. Stoddard, communicants are not so much as supposed
godly persons. This (Appeal, p. 43.) he says expressly, that by the institution communicants at the Lord’s supper
are not supposed to be real saints. And also asserts (Appeal, p. 76 ) that we are not obliged to believe visible
saints to be real saints. And it seems by what he says in his Appeal, (p. 17.) the church may admit persons to
communion, when at the same time they are aware that they are hypocrites. For there, in answer to Dr. Mather,
who had cited certain texts to prove, that when hypocrites do come into the church, they come in unawares; he
says, but neither of the places he cites proves that all hypocrites come in unawares. And in the next page he says,
The discovery of men’s hypocrisy is not the reason of their being cast out. Still evidently on the same foundation,
that some known hypocrites are fit to be admitted: for he says, (p. 15. d.) Such as being admitted may not be
cast out, are fit to be admitted. And these things are agreeable to what I know Mr. Stoddard’s church and con-
gregation have universally supposed to be his constant doctrine and practice among them. Thus it was, without
one dissenting voice among them, during the twenty-four years that I lived with them. And now the reader is
desired to judge, as Mr. W. would have him, whether my representing it to be the opinion of Mr. S and his ad-
herents, that persons might be admitted into the church without any notion of their being godly, or any respect
to such a character appearing on them, be unaccountable.—By these things it is evident. Mr. S—d’s scheme was
far from being what Mr. W. represents it to be, and pretends to maintain as his. And if the question he had to
controvert with me, were Mr. S—d’s question, as he asserts: yet he greatly mistakes the true state of the question,
though that be given as the title of his book.
1915
SECTION I. His concessions.