Peter and Peter, the most reverend presbyters and representatives of the most holy Pope
of Old Rome said: Let the most holy Tarasius, Patriarch of the royal city, say whether he
agrees (στοιχεῖ) with the letters of the most holy Pope of Old Rome or not.
Tarasius the most holy patriarch said: The divine Apostle Paul, who was filled with the
light of Christ, and who hath begotten us through the gospel, in writing to the Romans,
commending their zeal for the true faith which they had in Christ our true God, thus said:
“Your faith is gone forth into all the world.” It is necessary to follow out this witness, and
he that would contradict it is without good sense. Wherefore Hadrian, the ruler of Old
Rome, since he was a sharer of these things, thus borne witness to, wrote expressly and truly
to our religious Emperors, and to our humility, confirming admirably and beautifully the
ancient tradition of the Catholic Church. And we also ourselves, having examined both in
writing,524 and by inquisition, and syllogistically and by demonstration, and having been
taught by the teachings of the Fathers, so have confessed, so do confess, and so will confess;
and shall be fast, and shall remain, and shall stand firm in the sense of the letters which have
just been read, receiving the imaged representations according to the ancient tradition of
our holy fathers; and these we venerate with firmly-attached525 affection, as made in the
name of Christ our God, and of our Spotless Lady the Holy Mother of God, and of the Holy
Angels, and of all the Saints, most clearly giving our adoration and faith to the one only true
God.
And the holy Synod said: The whole holy Synod thus teaches.
539
Peter and Peter, the God-loved presbyters and legates of the Apostolic See, said: Let
the holy Synod say whether it receives the letters of the most holy Pope of Old Rome.
The holy Synod said: We follow, we receive, we admit them.
[The bishops then give one by one their votes all in the same sense.]
return. Some vagabond monks were persuaded by the Catholics to represent the Oriental patriarchs. This
curious anecdote is revealed by Theodore Studites, one of the warmest Iconoclasts of the age.” And yet to this
tissue of false statements Bury, in his just-published edition of Gibbon (1898), has no note of correction to
make! And this has passed, and will pass, for history among the overwhelming majority of English readers!
Nor does there seem to be any possible excuse for Gibbon in either particular, the first statement is proved to
be false by the letters of Hadrian, the second statement is equally disproved by the letters of the “high priests of
the East,” in which it is quite clear that no claim was set up that they represented the Patriarchs, but the Patri-
archates, which they did, as they proved, in a very real sense. This letter Gibbon must have seen, if indeed he
ever took the trouble to read the Acts, for it is spread out in full in Actio Secunda and was read at length to the
Council.
524 Mendham here has translated “The Scriptures,” following the Latin, the Greek is γραφικῶς.
525 Mendham translates σχετικῷ “relative,” which is a quite possible rendering.
1004
Extracts from the Acts. Session II.