TO PAMMACHIUS AGAINST JOHN OF JERUSALEM. 443
mistake which held them was not to be attrib-
uted to the Lord's body, but to the fact that
their eyes were closed, we are told : * " Their
eyes were opened, and they knew Him." Wherefore, also, Mary Magdalene so long as
she did not recognize Jesus, and sought the
living among the dead, thought He was the
gardener. Afterwards she recognized Him and then she called Him Lord. After His
resurrection Jesus was standing on the shore,
His disciples were in the ship. When the
others did not know Him, the disciple whom
Jesus loved5 said to Peter, " It is the Lord." For virginity is the first to recognize a virgin
body. He was the same, yet was not seen
alike by all as the same. And immediately it
is added, '"And no one durst ask Him, Who art Thou ? for they knew that He was the
Lord." No one durst, because they knew that He was God. They ate with Him at din-
ner because they saw He was a man and had
flesh ; not that He was one person as God,
another as man : but, being one and the same
Son of God, He was known as man, adored
as God. I suppose I must now air my phil-
osophy, and say that our senses are not to be
relied on, and especially sight. A * Carneades must be awaked from the dead to tell us the
truth — that an oar seems broken in the water,
porticos afar off look more magnificent, the
angles of towers seem rounded in the dis- tance, that the backs of pigeons change their
colours with every movement. When Rhoda* announced Peter, and told the Apostles, they
did not believe that he had escaped, on
account of the greatness of the danger, but
suspected it was a phantom. Moreover, in
passing through closed doors, He exhibited
the same power as in vanishing out of sight.
* Lynceus, as fable relates, used to see through a wall. Could not the Lord enter when the
doors were shut, unless He were a phantom ?
Eagles and vultures perceive dead bodies across the sea. Shall not the Saviour see
His Apostles without opening the door ? Tell
m.e, sharpest of disputants, which is greater,
to hang the vast weight of the earth on noth-
ing, and to balance it on the changing sur-
face of the waves ; or that God should pass
through a closed door, and the creature yield j to the Creator ? You allow the greater ; you !
object to the less. Peter7 walked upon the waters with his heavy and solid body. The
soft water does not yield : his faith doubts a
little, and immediately his body understands
its own nature ; that we may know that it
1 John xx. * John xxi. 7.
* Born at Cyrene about B.C. 213.
S Ib. 12.
He maintained that we can
be sure of nothing, neither through the senses, nor through the
understanding.
• Act* xii. * One of the Argonauts. T Matt. xiv. 28.
was not his body that walked on the water, but his faith.
36. I pray you, who use such elaborate
arguments against ths resurrection, let us
have some simple talk together. Do you be- lieve that our Lord really rose again in the
same body in which He died and was buried,
or do you not believe it ? If you believe it,
why do you make propositions which lead to
the denial of the resurrection ? If you do not
believe, you who thus try to deceive the minds
of the ignorant, and parade the word resur-
rection, though you mean* nothing by it, lis- ten to me. Not long ago, a certain disciple
of Marcion said : " Woe to him who rises again
with this flesh and these bones ! " Our heart
at once with joy replied,1 "We are buried to- gether, and we shall rise together with Christ
through baptism." " Do you speak of the
resurrection of the soul, or of the flesh?" I
answered, " Not that of the soul alone, but that of the flesh, which, together with the soul,
is born again in the laver. And how shall
that perish which has been born again in
Christ ? " " Because it is written," said he,
3" ' Flesh and blood shall not inherit the king-
dom of God.' " " I intreat you to mind what is
said — ' Flesh and blood shall not inherit the
kingdom of God.' " " It is said that they shall
not rise again." "Not at all, but only 'they
shall not inherit the kingdom.' " " How so ? "
" Because,' it follows,3 'neither shall corrup-
tion inherit incorruption.' So long then as they remain mere flesh and blood, they shall
not inherit the kingdom of God. But when
the 'corruptible shall have put on incorrup- tion, and the mortal shall have put on immor-
tality, and the clay of the flesh shall have been
made into a vessel, then that flesh which was
formerly kept down by a heavy weight upon
the earth, when once it has received the wings
of the spirit — wings which imply its change,
not its destruction — shall fly with fresh glory to heaven ; and then shall be fulfilled that
which is written, " ' Death is swallowed up in victory. Where, O death, is thy boasting ?
O death, where is thy sting ? ' ' 37. Reversing the order, we have given our
answer respecting the state of souls and the
resurrection of the flesh ; and, leaving out
the opening portions of the letter, we have con- fined ourselves to the refutation of this most
remarkable treatise. For we preferred to speak
of the things of God rather than of our own
wrongs. " If one man sin against another, they shall pray for him to the Lord. But if
he sin against God, who shall pray for him ?" In these days, on the contrary, we make it
our first business to pursue with undying 1 Rom. vi. 4. 4 Ib. 54. i Cor. xv. 50. Ib. 55- Mb. 0 i Sam. ii. 25.