500
Chapter 2.—2. Marcus of Mactaris1761 said: "It is not to be wondered at if heretics, being
enemies and opponents of the truth, claim to themselves what has been entrusted and
vouchsafed to other men. What is marvellous is that some of us, traitors to the truth, uphold
heretics and oppose Christians; therefore we decree that heretics should be baptized."1762
3. To him we answer: It is indeed much more to be wondered at, and deserving of ex-
pressions of great praise, that Cyprian and his colleagues had such love for unity that they
continued in unity with those whom they considered to be traitors to the truth, without any
apprehension of being polluted by them. For when Marcus said, "It is marvellous that some
of us, traitors to the truth, uphold heretics and oppose Christians," it seemed natural that
he should add, Therefore we decree that communion should not be held with them. This
he did not say; but what he does say is, "Therefore we decree that heretics should be baptized,"
adhering to what the peaceful Cyprian had enjoined in the first instance, saying, "Judging
no man, nor removing any from the right of communion if he entertain a different opinion."
While, therefore, the Donatists calumniate us and call us traditors, I should be glad to know,
supposing that any Jew or pagan were found, who, after reading the records of that Council
should call both us and them, according to their own rules, traitors to the truth, how we
should be able to make our joint defense so as to refute and wash away so grave a charge.
They give the name of traditors to men whom they were never able in times past to convict
of the offense, and whom they cannot now show to be involved in it, being themselves rather
shown to be liable to the same charge. But what has this to do with us? What shall we say
of them who, by their own showing, are unquestionably traitors? For if we, however falsely,
are called traditors, because, as they allege, we took part in the same communion with
traditors, we have all taken part with the traditors in question, seeing that in the time of the
blessed Cyprian the party of Donatus had not yet separated itself from unity. For the delivery
of the sacred books, from which they began to be called traditors, occurred somewhat more
than forty years after his martyrdom. If, therefore, we are traditors, because we sprang
from traditors, as they believe or pretend, we both of us derive our origin from those other
traitors. For there is no room for saying that they did not communicate with these traitors,
since they call them men of their own party. In the words of the Council which they are
most forward to quote, "Some of us," it declares, "traitors to the truth, uphold heretics." To
this is added the testimony of Cyprian, showing clearly that he remained in communion
with them, when he says, "Judging no man, nor removing any from the right of communion
if he entertain a different opinion." For those who entertained a different opinion were the
very persons whom Marcus calls traitors to the truth because they upheld heretics, as he
1761 Mactaris (Macthari) was in ecclesiastical province of Byzacium. This bishop is probably the Marcus of
Cypr. Ep. lxx.
1762 Conc. Carth. sec. 38.
Chapter 2
921
Chapter 2