In Mr. W.‘s reply to my answer to the first objection, (p. 81, &c.) he wholly leaves the
argument, and writes in support and defence of other matters, quite different from those
which I mentioned, or had any concern with. The objection which I mentioned, and which
had been much insisted on by some against my opinion, was, That church-members are
called disciples, or scholars; a name, that gives us a notion of the visible church as a school;
and leads us to suppose, that all who profess that sort of faith and sincerity, which implies
a disposition to seek christian learning and spiritual attainments, are qualified for admission.
But Mr. W. says nothing at all in support of this objection. In answer to it, I endeavoured
to show, that the name disciples given to church-members, does not argue that unsanctified
persons are fit to be members. He says nothing to show that it does. He says, if it will not
follow from Christ’s visible church being represented as Christ’s school, that it is in order
to all good attainments; yet it is in order to all that they have not yet attained. Which is
nothing to the purpose, but foreign to the thing in debate, viz. Whether sanctifying grace is
one of those things which are not yet attained by those that are lawfully in the church. He
there says nothing to prove that it is; and especially to prove it from the meaning of the
word, disciples; which was the argument in hand. He insists, that men may be sufficiently
subject to Christ as their master and teacher, in order to be in his school or church, without
grace: but then the thing to be proved, was, that church-members being called disciples
makes this evident, in order to support the argument or objection I was upon: which argu-
ment is entirely neglected throughout all his discourse under this head.
So in his reply to my answer to the eleventh objection, (p. 123, &c.) he wholly neglects
the argument, and labours to support a different one. I endeavoured, without concerning
myself about the words of any argument in Mr. Stoddard’s Appeal, to answer an argument
abundantly used at Northampton against my doctrine, of unsanctified men not having a
right to come to the Lord’s supper; which was this, “You may as well say, that unsanctified
men may not attend any other duty of worship:” and particularly, “You may as well forbid
them to pray.”—As for Mr. S.‘s objection, in these words, “If unsanctified men may attend
all other ordinances or duties of worship, then they may lawfully attend the Lord’s supper;”
it was an argument I was not obliged to attend to in the words in which he delivered it, be-
cause it was not an argument brought against my scheme of things, but one very diverse:
since it is not my opinion, that unsanctified men may attend all other ordinances, or duties
of worship, besides the Lord’s supper; for I do not suppose, such may offer themselves to
baptism; which Mr. S. takes for granted, in his argument. And therefore what Mr. W. says
in support of it, is quite beside the business. As to the argument I was concerned with, taken
especially from the lawfulness of unsanctified men praying, to prove, that therefore it must
Now is it reasonable to suppose, that such men have the proper qualifications, by divine institution, for a lawful
right to be members of the visible family of God?
1978
SECTION III. Irrelevant arguments.