yet among the works of the flesh, of which it is said that they who do them shall not inherit
the kingdom of God, the apostle places this in an enumeration in which heresies also are
specified: “Now the works of the flesh,” he says, “are manifest, which are these: adultery,
fornication, uncleanness, lasciviousness, idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance, emulations,
wrath, strife, seditions, heresies, envyings, murders, drunkenness, revellings, and such like;
of the which I tell you before, as I have also told you in time past, that they who do such
things shall not inherit the kingdom of God.”2269 Baptism, therefore, although it was admin-
istered after John, is not administered after a heretic, on the very same principle according
to which, though administered after John; it is not administered after an intemperate man:
for both heresies and drunkenness are among the works which exclude those who do them
from inheriting the kingdom of God. Does it not seem to you as if it were a thing intolerably
unseemly, that although baptism was repeated after it had been administered by him who,
not even moderately drinking wine, but wholly refraining from its use, prepared the way
for the kingdom of God, and yet that it should not be repeated after being administered by
an intemperate man, who shall not inherit the kingdom of God? What can be said in answer
to this, but that the one was the baptism of John, after which the apostle administered the
baptism of Christ; and that the other, administered by an intemperate man, was the baptism
of Christ? Between John Baptist and an intemperate man there is a great difference, as of
opposites; between the baptism of Christ and the baptism of John there is no contrariety,
but a great difference. Between the apostle and an intemperate man there is a great difference;
but there is none between the baptism of Christ administered by an apostle, and the baptism
of Christ administered by an intemperate man. In like manner, between John and a heretic
there is a great difference, as of opposites; and between the baptism of John and the baptism
of Christ which a heretic administers there is no contrariety, but there is a great difference.
But between the baptism of Christ which an apostle administers, and the baptism of Christ
which a heretic administers, there is no difference. For the form of the sacrament is acknow-
ledged to be the same even when there is a great difference in point of worth between the
men by whom it is administered.
49. But pardon me, for I have made a mistake in wishing to convince you by arguing
from the case of an intemperate man administering baptism; for I had forgotten that I am
dealing with a Rogatist, not with one bearing the wider name of Donatist. For among your
colleagues who are so few, and in the whole number of your clergy, perhaps you cannot find
one addicted to this vice. For you are persons who hold that the name Catholic is given to
the faith not because communion of those who hold it embraces the whole world, but because
they observe the whole of the Divine precepts and the whole of the sacraments; you are the
persons in whom alone the Son of man when He cometh shall find faith, when on the earth
2269 Gal. v. 19–21.
877
To Vincentius