Book u.] ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 93
as a proportion established in bodies remains unaffected and
secure, though it be lost to sight in a thousand cases; so
must souls, if they are not material, as is asserted, retain
their knowledge* of the past, however thoroughly they may
have been enclosed in bodies. Moreover, the same reason-
ing not only shows that they are not incorporeal, but deprives
them of all? immortality even, and refers them to the limits
within which life is usually closed. For whatever is led by
some inducement to change and alter itself, so that it cannot
retain its natural state, must of necessity be considered
essentially passive. But that which is liable and exposed to
suffering, is declared to be corruptible by that very capacity
of suffering.
27. So then, if souls lose all their knowledge on being
fettered with the body, they must experience something of
such a nature that it makes them become blindly forgetful.*
For they cannot, without becoming subject to anything what-
ever, either lay aside their knowledge while they maintain
their natural state, or without change in themselves pass into
a different state. Nay, we rather think that what is one, im-
mortal, simple, in whatever it may be, must always retain its
own nature, and that it neither should nor could be subject
to anything, if indeed it purposes to endure and abide within
the limits of true immortality. For all suffering is a passage
for death and destruction, a way leading to the grave, and
bringing an end of life which may not be escaped from;
and if souls are liable to it, and yield to its influence and
assaults, they indeed have life given to them only for present
use, not as a secured possession, although some come to
other conclusions, and put faith in their own arguments
with regard to so important a matter.
28. And yet, that we may not be as ignorant when we
1 Lit., ** not suffer forgetfulness.”
? Lit. *however the most solid unions of bodies may have bound
them round."
3 So the edd., reading privat immortalitate has omni, for which, according
to Hildebrand, the vs, reads -tatem has omnis—‘‘all these of immortality.”
* Lit., ‘‘ put on the blindness of oblivion.”
5 Cf. Lucretius, iii, 969, where life is thus spoken of.