366
17. In the passages containing the commandments also, similar things are found. For
in the law Moses is commanded to destroy every male that is not circumcised on the eighth
day, which is exceedingly incongruous; 2777 since it would be necessary, if it were related
that the law was executed according to the history, to command those parents to be punished
who did not circumcise their children, and also those who were the nurses of little children.
The declaration of Scripture now is, “The uncircumcised male, i.e., who shall not have been
circumcised, shall be cut off from his people.” 2778 And if we are to inquire regarding the
impossibilities of the law, we find an animal called the goat-stag, 2779 which cannot possibly
exist, but which, as being in the number of clean beasts, Moses commands to be eaten; and
a griffin, 2780 which no one ever remembers or heard of as yielding to human power, but
which the legislator forbids to be used for food. Respecting the celebrated 2781 observance
of the Sabbath also he thus speaks: “Ye shall sit, everyone in your dwellings; no one shall
move from his place on the Sabbath-day.” 2782 Which precept it is impossible to observe
literally; for no man can sit a whole day so as not to move from the place where he sat down.
With respect to each one of these points now, those who belong to the circumcision, and
all who would have no more meaning to be found in sacred Scripture than what is indicated
by the letter, consider that there should be no investigation regarding the goat-stag, and the
griffin, and the vulture; and they invent some empty and trifling tales about the Sabbath,
drawn from some traditional sources or other, alleging that everyone’s place is computed
to him within two thousand cubits. 2783 Others, again, among whom is Dositheus the
Samaritan, censure indeed expositions of this kind, but themselves lay down something
more ridiculous, viz., that each one must remain until the evening in the posture, place, or
position in which he found himself on the Sabbath-day; i.e., if found sitting, he is to sit the
whole day, or if reclining, he is to recline the whole day. Moreover, the injunction which
runs, “Bear no burden on the Sabbath-day,” 2784 seems to me an impossibility. For the
Jewish doctors, in consequence of these (prescriptions), have betaken themselves, as the
holy apostle says, to innumerable fables, saying that it is not accounted a burden if a man
2777 Inconsequens.
2778 Cf. Gen. xvii. 14.
2779 Tragelaphus; “wild goat,” Auth. Vers. Deut. xiv. 5; Heb. וֹקּאַ ,ἅπαξ λεγ.
2780 Gryphus; “ossifrage,” Auth. Vers. Lev. xi. 13; Heb. סרֶפֶ.
2781 Opinatissimâ.
2782 Cf. Ex. xvi. 29.
2783 Ulnas.
2784 Jer. xvii. 21.
782
Chapter I., Sections 1-23 translated from the Latin of Rufinus: That the…