AGAINST VIGILANTIUS. 423
that while sowing spiritual things he must
reap your carnal things. As for his argument
that they who keep what they have, and dis-
tribute among the poor, little by little, the in-
crease of their property, act more wisely than
they who sell their possessions, and once for
all give all away, not I but the Lord shall
make answer : l " If thou wilt be perfect, go sell all that thou hast and give to the poor,
and come, follow Me." He speaks to him who wishes to be perfect, who, with the Apos-
tles, leaves father, ship, and net. The man
whom you approve stands in the second or
third rank ; yet we welcome him provided it
be understood that the first is to be preferred
to the second, and the second to the third.
15. Let me add that our monks are not to
"be deterred from their resolution by you with
your viper's tongue and savage bite. Your argument respecting them runs thus : If all men were to seclude themselves and live in
solitude, who is there to frequent the churches? Who will remain to win those
engaged in secular pursuits? Who will be
able to urge sinners to virtuous conduct?
Similarly, if all were as silly as you, who
could be wise? And, to follow out your ar-
gument, virginity would not deserve our ap- probation. For if all were virgins, we should
have no marriages ; the race would perish ;
infants would not cry in their cradles ; mid-
wives would lose their pay and turn beggars ;
and Dormitantius, all alone and shrivelled
up with cold, would lie awake in his bed.
The truth is, virtue is a rare thing and not
eagerly sought after by the many. Would that all were as the few of whom it is said :
2 " Many are called, few are chosen." The prison would be empty. But, indeed, a
monk's function is not to teach, but to lament ; to mourn either for himself or for
the world, and with terror to anticipate our
Lord's advent. Knowing his own weakness and the frailty of the vessel which he carries,
he is afraid of stumbling, lest he strike
against something, and it fall and be broken.
Hence he shuns the sight of women, and par-
ticularly of young women, and so far chastens himself as to dread even what is safe.
1 6. Why, you will say, go to the desert?
The reason is plain : That I may not hear or
see you ; that I may not be disturbed by your
madness ; that I may not be engaged in con-
flict with you ; that the eye of the harlot
may not lead me captive ; that beauty may
1 Matt. xix. si. * Matt. xx. 16 : xxii. 14.
not lead me to unlawful embraces. You will
reply : " This is not to fight, but to run away. Stand in line of battle, put on your armour
and resist your foes, so that, having overcome,
you may wear the crown.'' I confess my weakness. I would not fight in the hope of
victory, lest some time or other I lose the
victory. If I flee, I avoid the sword ; if I
stand, I must either overcome or fall. But
what need is there for me to let go certainties and follow after uncertainties ? Either with
my shield or with my feet I must shun death.
You who fight may either be overcome or
may overcome. I who fly do not overcome,
inasmuch as I fly ; but I fly to make sure
that I may not be overcome. There is no
safety in sleep with a serpent beside you.- Possibly he will not bite me, yet it is possible
that after a time he may bite me. We call women mothers who are no older than sisters
and daughters,1 and we do not blush to cloak our vices with the names of piety. What
business has a monk in the women's cells? What is the meaning of secret conversation
and looks which shun the presence of wit-
nesses ? Holy love has no restless desire.
Moreover, what we have said respecting lust
we must apply to avarice, and to all vices
which are avoided by solitude. We therefore
keep clear of the crowded cities, that we may
not be compelled to do what we are urged to
do, not so much by nature as by choice.
17. At the request of the reverend presby-
ters, as I have said, I have devoted to the dic-
tation of these remarks the labour of a single
night, for my brother Sisinnius is hastening
his departure for Egypt, where he has relief to
give to the saints, and is impatient to be gone.
If it were not so, however, the subject itself
was so openly blasphemous as to call for the
indignation of a writer rather than a mul-
titude of proofs. But if Dormitantius wakes
up that he may again abuse me, and if he
thinks fit to disparage me with that same
blasphemous mouth with which he pulls to
pieces Apostles and martyrs, I will spend
upon him something more than this short
lucubration. I will keep vigil for a whole
night in his behalf and in behalf of his com-
panions, whether they be disciples or masters,
who think no man to be worthy of Christ's ministry unless he is married and his wife is seen to be with child.
1 He seems to mean that monks spoke of young ladies as
Mothers of the Convents, so as to .be able to frequent their so-
ciety without reproach.