The most reverend bishops cried out: This is a just sentence. So we all say. These things
please us all. This is a just determination. Establish the proposed form of decree. This is
a just vote. All has been decreed as should be. We beg you to let us go. By the safety of the
Emperor let us go. We all will remain in this opinion, we all say the same things.
Lucentius, the bishop, said: The Apostolic See gave orders that all things should be
done in our presence [This sentence reads in the Latin: The Apostolic See ought not to be
humiliated in our presence. I do not know why Canon Bright in his notes on Canon XXVIII.
has followed this reading]; and therefore whatever yesterday was done to the prejudice of
the canons during our absence, we beseech your highness to command to be rescinded.
But if not, let our opposition be placed in the minutes, and pray let us know clearly [Lat.
that we may know] what we are to report to that most apostolic bishop who is the ruler of
the whole church, so that he may be able to take action with regard to the indignity done
to his See and to the setting at naught of the canons.
[John, the most reverend bishop of Sebaste, said: We all will remain of the opinion ex-
pressed by your magnificence.300]
The most glorious judges said: The whole synod has approved what we proposed.
Notes.
Hefele.
(Hist. Counc., Vol. III., p. 428.)
That is, the prerogative assigned to the Church of Constantinople is, in spite of the op-
position of the Roman legate decreed by the Synod. Thus ended the Council of Chalcedon
after it had lasted three weeks.
How it is possible after reading the foregoing proceedings to imagine for an instant that
the bishops of this Council considered the rights they were discussing to be of Divine origin,
and that the occupant of the See of Rome was, jure divino, supreme over all pontiffs I cannot
understand. It is quite possible, of course, to affirm, as some have done, that the acts, as we
have them, have been mutilated, but the contention involves not only many difficulties but
also no few absurdities; and yet I cannot but think that even this extreme hypothesis is to
be preferred to any attempt to reconcile the acts as we now have them with the acceptance
on the part of the members of the council of the doctrine of a jure divino Papal Supremacy
as it is now held by the Latin Church.
300 These words are found only in the Latin.
548
Extracts from the Acts. Session XVI.