Chapter
XVII.
In what follows, Celsus, assailing the Mosaic
history, finds fault with those who give it a tropical and allegorical
signification. And here one might say to this great man, who
inscribed upon his own work the title of a
True Discourse
,
“Why, good sir, do you make it a boast to have it recorded that
the gods should engage in such adventures as are described by your
learned poets and philosophers, and be guilty of abominable intrigues,
and of engaging in wars against their own fathers, and of cutting off
their secret parts, and should dare to commit and to suffer such
enormities; while Moses, who gives no such accounts respecting God, nor
even regarding the holy angels, and who relates deeds of far less
atrocity regarding men (for in his writings no one ever ventured to
commit such crimes as Kronos did against Uranus, or Zeus against his
father, or that of the father of men and gods, who had intercourse with
his own daughter), should be considered as having deceived those who
were placed under his laws, and to have led them into
error?” And here Celsus seems to me to act somewhat as
Thrasymachus the Platonic philosopher did, when he would not allow
Socrates to answer regarding justice, as he wished, but said,
“Take care not to say that utility is justice, or duty, or
anything of that kind.” For in like manner Celsus assails
(as he thinks) the Mosaic histories, and finds fault with those who
understand them allegorically, at the same time bestowing also some
praise upon those who do so, to the effect that they are more impartial
(than those who do not); and thus, as it were, he prevents by his
cavils those who are able to show the true state of the case from
offering such a defence as they would wish to offer.
3108
3108
Οἱονεὶ
κωλύεται,
κατηγορήσας
ὡς βούλεται,
ἀπολογεῖσθαι
τοὺς
δυναμένους
ὡς πέφυκεν
ἔχειν τὰ
πράγματα
. We have taken
κωλύεται
as
middle. Some propose
κωλύει
. And we have
read
βούλονταί
, a lection which is given by a second hand in one
ms.