LETTER CXLIV.
28=
ers at Csesarea that you " have resolved to have all definitions of dogma reviewed by lay
judges, sitting by general invitation, and in-
vestigating all points touching the faith."
And you continue : " the divine mercy has made it possible for them to put forward their
views in a positive and definite form, which
your modest ability has reinforced with a
great weight of evidence." Now it is this
" great weight of evidence " which I am so anxious to obtain. For, so far as I can see,
your one aim has been to refute your oppo-
nents when they deny that our souls are the
handiwork of God. If they hold such a view,
you are right in thinking that it should be
condemned. Were they to say the same thing
of our bodies, they would be forced to retract
it, or else be held up to execration. For what
Christian can deny that every single human
body is the work of God ? Yet when we ad-
mit that they are of divine origin we do not
mean to deny that they are humanly engen- dered. When therefore it is asserted that our
souls are procreated from a kind of immate-
rial seed, and that they, like our bodies,
come to us from our parents, yet are made
souls by the working of God, it is not by hu-
man guesses that the assertion is to be re-
futed, but by the witness of divine scripture.
Numbers of passages may indeed be quoted from the sacred books which have canonical
authority, to prove that our souls are God's handiwork. But such passages only refute
thoM- who deny that each several human soul is made by God ; not at all those who while
they admit this contend that, like our bodies,
they are formed by divine agency through
the instrumentality of parents. To refute
these you must look for unmistakable texts ;
or, if you have already discovered such, shew
your affection by communicating them to me.
For though I seek them most diligently I fail to find them.
A> >tated shortly by yourself (at the end
of your letter to the brothers at Caesarea)
your dilemma is as follows: "Inasmuch as I am your son and disciple and have but re-
cently by God's help come to consider these mysteries, I beg you with your priestly wis-
dom to teach me which of two opposite views
I ought to hold. Am I to maintain that souls
are transmitted by generation, and that they
are derived in some mysterious way from
Adam our first-formed father?1 Or am I
with your brothers and the priests who are
here to hold that God has been, is, and will
be the author and maker of all things and all
men ? " 6. Of the two alternatives which vou thus
1 Wisdom x. i.
put forward you wish to be urged to choose
one or other ; and this would be the course
of wisdom if your alternatives were so con-
trary that the choice of one would involve
the rejection of the other. But as it is, in-
stead of selecting one of them a man may say
that they are both true. He may maintain that the souls of all mankind are derived from
Adam our first-formed father, and yet believe
and assert that God has been, is, and will be
the author and maker of all things and all
men. How on your principles is such a man
to be confuted ? Shall we say : " If they are transmitted by generation God is not their
author, for He does not make them ? " In
that case he will reply : " Bodies too are en- gendered and not made by God ; on your
shewing, then He is not their author." Will any one maintain that God is the maker of
no bodies but Adam's which He made out
of the dust and Eve's which He formed out of
Adam's side ; and that other bodies are not made by Him because they are engendered
by human parents ?
7. If your opponents go so far in maintain-
ing the derivation of souls as to deny that
they are made and formed by God, you may
use this argument as a weapon to confute
them so far as God's help enables you. But
if, while they assert that the soul's beginnings come from Adam first and then from a man's
parents, they, at the same time hold that the
soul in every man is created and formed by
God the author of all things, they can only
be confuted out of scripture. Search there-
fore till you find a passage that is neither
obscure nor capable of a double meaning ; or
if you have already found one, hand it on to
me as I have begged you to do. But if, like
myself, you have so far failed to discover any
such passage, you must still strain every nerve
to confute those who say that souls are in no
sense God's handiwork. This seems to be
your opponents' position, for in your first let-
ter you write that "they have secretly whis- pered scandalous doctrines and have forsaken
your communion and the obedience of the
church on account of this foolish, nay im-
pious opinion." Against such men defend and uphold by every possible expedient the
docirine you have laid down in the same let-
ter, that God has been, is, and will be the
maker of souls ; and that every thing in heaven
and on earth owes its existence wholly to
Him. For this is true of every creature ;
and as such is to be believed, asserted, de-
fended, and proved. God has been, is, and
will be the author and maker of all things
and all men as you have told your fellow-
bishops of the province of Cassarea, exhort-
ing them to adopt the doctrine by the ex-