Book XXIV.
Faustus explains the Manichæan denial that man was made by God as applying to the
fleshly man not to the spiritual. Augustin elucidates the Apostle Paul’s contrasts between
flesh and spirit so as to exclude the Manichæan view.
1. Faustus said: We are asked the reason for our denial that man is made by God. But
317
we do not assert that man is in no sense made by God; we only ask in what sense, and when,
and how. For, according to the apostle, there are two men, one of whom he calls sometimes
the outer man, generally the earthy, sometimes, too, the old man: the other he calls the inner
or heavenly or new man. 983 The question is, Which of these is made by God? For there
are likewise two times of our nativity; one when nature brought us forth into this light,
binding us in the bonds of flesh; and the other, when the truth regenerated us on our con-
version from error and our entrance into the faith. It is this second birth of which Jesus
speaks in the Gospel, when He says, "Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom
of God."984 Nicodemus, not knowing what Christ meant, was at a loss, and inquired how
this could be, for an old man could not enter into his mother’s womb and be born a second
time. Jesus said in reply, "Except a man be born of water and of the Holy Spirit, he cannot
see the kingdom of God." Then He adds, "That which is born of the flesh is flesh; and that
which is born of the Spirit is spirit." Hence, as the birth in which our bodies originate is not
the only birth, but there is another in which we are born again in spirit, an important
question arises from this distinction as to which of those births it is in which God makes
us. The manner of birth also is twofold. In the humiliating process of ordinary generation,
we spring from the heat of animal passion; but when we are brought into the faith, we are
formed under good instruction in honor and purity in Jesus Christ, by the Holy Spirit. For
this reason, in all religion, and especially in the Christian religion, young children are invited
to membership. This is hinted at in the words of His apostle: "My little children, of whom
I travail in birth again until Christ be formed in you."985 The question, then, is not whether
God makes man, but what man He makes, and when, and how. For if it is when we are
fashioned in the womb that God forms us after His own image, which is the common belief
of Gentiles and Jews, and which is also your belief, then God makes the old man, and pro-
duces us by means of sensual passion, which does not seem suitable to His divine nature.
But if it is when we are converted and brought to a better life that we are formed by God,
which is the general doctrine of Christ and His apostles, and which is also our doctrine, in
this case God makes us new men, and produces us in honor and purity, which would agree
perfectly with His sacred and adorable majesty. If you do not reject Paul’s authority, we
983 Rom. vi., vii.; 1 Cor. xv.; 2 Cor. iv.; Eph. iii., iv.; and Col. iii.
984 John iii. 3.
985 Gal. iv. 19.
Faustus explains the Manichæan denial that man was made by God as applying to the fleshly man not to the spiritual. Augustin elucidates the Apostle Paul’s contrasts between flesh and spirit so as to exclude the Manichæan view.
540
Faustus explains the Manichæan denial that man was made by God as applying…