read in Deuteronomy: "These precepts which I deliver unto thee this day, O Israel, thou
shalt observe to do; thou shalt not turn aside from them to the right hand or to the left; thou
shalt not add thereto nor diminish from it, that thy God may bless thee."635 Whether,
therefore, Jesus turned aside to the right by adding to the law and the prophets in order to
fulfill them, or to the left in taking away from them to destroy them, either way he offended
the author of the law. So this verse must either have some other meaning, or be spurious.
3. Augustin replied: What amazing folly, to disbelieve what Matthew records of Christ,
while you believe Manichæus! If Matthew is not to be believed because he was not present
when Christ said, "I came not to destroy the law and the prophets, but to fulfill," was
Manichæus present, was he even born, when Christ appeared among men? According,
then, to your rule, you should not believe anything that Manichæus says of Christ. On the
other hand, we refuse to believe what Manichæus says of Christ; not because he was not
present as a witness of Christ’s words and actions, but because he contradicts Christ’s dis-
ciples, and the Gospel which rests on their authority. The apostle, speaking in the Holy
Spirit, tells us that such teachers would arise. With reference to such, he says to believers:
"If any man preaches to you another gospel than that ye have received, let him be ac-
cursed."636 If no one can say what is true of Christ unless he has himself seen and heard
Him, no one now can be trusted. But if believers can now say what is true of Christ because
the truth has been handed down in word or writing by those who saw and heard, why might
not Matthew have heard the truth from his fellow-disciple John, if John was present and he
himself was not, as from the writings of John both we who are born so long after and those
who shall be born after us can learn the truth about Christ? In this way, the Gospels of Luke
and Mark, who were companions of the disciples, as well as the Gospel of Matthew, have
the same authority as that of John. Besides, the Lord Himself might have told Matthew
what those called before him had already been witnesses of. Your idea is, that John should
have recorded this saying of the Lord, as he was present on the occasion. As if it might not
happen that, since it was impossible to write all that be heard from the Lord, he set himself
to write some, omitting this among others. Does he not say at the close of his Gospel: "And
there are also many other things which Jesus did, the which, if they should be written every
one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that should be writ-
ten"?637 This proves that he omitted many things intentionally. But if you choose John as
an authority regarding the law and the prophets, I ask you only to believe his testimony to
them. It is John who writes that Isaiah saw the glory of Christ.638 It is in his Gospel we find
635 Deut. xii. 32.
636 Gal. i. 9.
637 John xxi. 25.
638 John xii. 41.
401
Faustus rejects Christ’s declaration that He came not to destroy the law…