Therefore persons cannot reasonably make this improvement of the doctrine of necessity,
that they will go into a voluntary negligence of Means for their own happiness. For the
principles they must go upon, in order to this, are inconsistent with their making any im-
provement at all of the doctrine: for to make some improvement of it, is to be influenced
by it, to come to some voluntary conclusion, in regard to their own conduct, with some
view or aim: but this, as has been shown, is inconsistent with the principles they pretend to
act upon. In short, the principles are such as cannot he acted upon at all, or, in any respect,
consistently. And, therefore, in every pretence of acting upon them, or making any improve-
ment at all of them, there is a self-contradiction.
As to that objection against the doctrine, which I have endeavoured to prove, that it
makes men no more than mere machines; I would say, that notwithstanding this doctrine,
man is entirely, perfectly, and unspeakably different from a mere machine, in that he has
reason and understanding, with a faculty of Will, and so is capable of volition and choice;
in that his Will is guided by the dictates or views of his understanding; and in that his ex-
ternal actions and behaviour, and in many respects also his thoughts, and the exercises of
his mind, are subject to his Will; so that he has liberty to act according to his choice, and
do what he pleases; and by means of these things, is capable of moral habits and moral acts,
such inclinations and actions as, according to the common sense of mankind, are worthy
of praise, esteem, love, and reward; or, on the contrary, of disesteem, detestation, indignation,
and punishment.
In these things is all the difference from mere machines, as to liberty and agency, that
would be any perfection, dignity, or privilege, in any respect: all the difference that can be
desired, and all that can be conceived of; and indeed all that the pretensions of the Arminians
themselves come to, as they are forced often to explain themselves; though their explications
overthrow and abolish the things asserted, and pretended to be explained. For they are
69
forced to explain a self-determining power of Will, by a power in the soul, to determine as
it chooses or wills; which comes to no more than this, that a man has a power of choosing,
and, in many instances, can do as he chooses. Which is quite a different thing from that
contradiction, his having power of choosing his first act of choice in the case.
Or, if their scheme make any other difference than this, between men and machines, it
is for the worse: it is so far from supposing men to have a dignity and privilege above ma-
chines, that it makes the manner of their being determined still more unhappy. Whereas,
machines are guided by an intelligent cause, by the skilful hand of the workman or owner;
the will of man is left to the guidance of nothing, but absolute blind contingence!
705
SECTION V. Objections, that this scheme of Necessity renders all Means…