II. Concerning Ecumenical Councils in General.
An Ecumenical Synod may be defined as a synod the decrees of which have found ac-
ceptance by the Church in the whole world.2 It is not necessary to make a council ecumen-
ical that the number of bishops present should be large, there were but 325 at Nice, and 150
xii
at I. Constantinople; it is not necessary that it should be assembled with the intention of its
being ecumenical, such was not the case with I. Constantinople; it is not necessary that all
parts of the world should have been represented or even that the bishops of such parts should
have been invited. All that is necessary is that its decrees find ecumenical acceptance after-
wards, and its ecumenical character be universally recognized.
The reader will notice that in the foregoing I have not proceeded from the theological
foundation of what an Ecumenical Synod should be (with this question the present volume
has nothing to do), but from a consideration of the historical question as to what the Seven
Councils have in common, which distinguishes them from the other councils of the Chris-
tian Church.
And here it is well to note that there have been many “General Councils” which have
not been “Ecumenical.” It is true that in ordinary parlance we often use the expressions as
interchangeable, but such really is not the case. There are but seven universally recognized
and undisputed “Ecumenical Councils”; on the other hand, the number of “General Councils”
is very considerable, and as a matter of fact of these last several very large ones fell into
heresy. It is only necessary to mention as examples the Latrocinium and the spurious
“Seventh Council,” held by the iconoclastic heretics. It is therefore the mere statement of
an historical fact to say that General Councils have erred.
The Ecumenical Councils claimed for themselves an immunity from error in their
doctrinal and moral teaching, resting such claim upon the promise of the presence and
2 This was until the division of the East and West the definition accepted by all the whole Christian world.
But since the Church has been divided, while the East has kept to the old definition and has not pretended to
have held any Ecumenical Councils, the Roman Church has made a new definition of the old term and has then
proceeded to hold a very considerable number of synods which she recognizes as Ecumenical. I say “a very
considerable number,” for even among Roman Catholic theologians there is much dispute as to the number of
these “Ecumenical Synods,” the decrees of which, like those of Trent and the Vatican, have never been received
by about half of the Christian world, including four of the five patriarchates and of the fifth patriarchate all the
Anglican communion. According to modern Roman writers the definition of these non-ecumenically received
Ecumenical Synods is “Ecumenical councils are those to which the bishops and others entitled to vote are con-
voked from the whole world under the Presidency of the Pope or his legates, and the decrees of which, having
received Papal confirmation, bind all Christians.” Addis and Arnold, A Catholic Dictionary, s. v. Councils. The
reader will notice that by this definition one at least (I. Constantinople), probably three, of the seven undisputed
Ecumenical Synods cease to be such.
Concerning Ecumenical Councils in General.
7
Concerning Ecumenical Councils in General.